A Script By: Christopher McQuarrie - The Usual Suspects
Before it was a film, it was a script. Brad Koszo dives deep into some of Hollywood's most celebrated screenplays to analyze their structure, themes, and page-to-film journey. Get ready for a look at the writers behind the words as he explore their...
Brad Koszo dives deep into some of Hollywood's most celebrated screenplays to analyze their structure, themes, and page-to-film journey. Get ready for a look at the writers behind the words as he explore their process, what influenced them, and how they inspired some of the iconic cinema we enjoy today.
This month, Brad and Angela unravel the words of Christopher McQuarrie's brilliant Academy Award-winning script that introduced us to Keyser Soze and The Usual Suspects!
Check out our NEW YouTube Channel and subscribe now!
Head over to our Patreon and get started with a FREE 7-day trial. We've got plenty of exclusive content and episodes that you'll only find there! You can also sign up as a free member!
www.afilmbypodcast.com/ for more information.
Email us at afilmbypodcast@gmail.com with your questions, comments, and requests.
Find us on Instagram, X, and Facebook @afilmbypodcast.
0:01 Welcome to A Film By Presents, A Script By. I am your host, Brad Kozo, and on this show, we break down some of Hollywood's most celebrated screenplays and examine their conception, execution, and legacy. In this episode, we will unravel the mystery of Kaiser Soze as we dive into Christopher McQuarrie's screenplay for The Usual Suspects. Blending elements of the crime thriller, film noir, heist film, and detective mystery, The Usual Suspect turns storytelling itself into an act of deception. The screenplay gives us the facts, but filters them through a narrator who rearranges their meaning and exploits our desire for a clear answer. By the time the truth is revealed, the script hasn't simply fooled us, it makes us question how much of the story we ever truly understood. This is a script by Let's Turn the Page.
0:55 The greatest trick the devil ever pulled was convincing. The world he didn't exist. That is just one of the many brilliant lines in today's screenplay, The Usual Suspects, written by Christopher McQuarrie. The film became a major breakthrough for many of the people involved. Bryan Singer's direction, McQuarrie's Oscar-winning screenplay, to the memorable performances of its ensemble cast.
1:39 But first, as always, I have to welcome back today's guest. She was fantastic when she joined us for our episode on Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, and now she's back. Please welcome back Angela Norris. Angela? How are you? I'm doing fantastic. It's great to be back, so thank you so much for having me. Thank you for doing this one. This is one of my absolute favorites, so I'm excited. It's a movie that's just kind of like, if you need something, a satisfaction of, I need something that I know is going to be satisfying. Yes. Here you go. Even though I won't have all of my questions answered, it's just still phenomenal. When did you first see it, and what did you think when you first saw it?
2:22 I actually didn't see it till a few years after it had come out when I was working at a video store and it became highly recommended. And I absolutely loved it. I love good psychological thrillers, you know, throw that detective spin in there. It was obviously a fantastic cast. So, yeah, I remember taking it home and just absolutely loving it. And of course, you know, Kevin Spacey became like one of my favorites to watch. I mean, I've seen him in other things, but this definitely like, I'm like, I really enjoyed his work. And I, you know, after that made sure pretty much watched everything, you know, he was in.
3:03 But yeah, and it's just still one of those that I will go to every now and then. And even though, you know, there's still, like I mentioned, unanswered questions, I'm okay with that because just the mystery and the fantastic reveal, it's just one of the best, like, Oh, it's like, even though it's like part of your voice, like, you know, in the back of your head, you get this inkling of like, I'm getting these tingles, but you know what? I'm enjoying this too much that I don't want to read so much in the tingles. I just, I just want to be here for. The, you know, the right of it. And now everything unfolds and just, you know, one thing after another. So, um, I, I'm, I'm glad it was recommended to me and, and I, uh, yeah, I've been a fan of it. So probably about 99, I think I maybe saw like four or five years after it came out. I, I remember I actually missed this in the theater.
3:55 And it's funny enough because I'm supposed to be the film geek in my family. But my older brother got the jump on me for this movie. Okay. Somehow just him. He got to see it. And he's like, you've got to see this movie, The Usual Suspects. And I was like, I heard very, very little about it. But he's like, it's perfect. It's amazing. And damn it, he was right. But I missed it in the theater still. I tried to find it, but it was gone. But once it came on video, I was able to see it. And it was like, oh, yeah, I'm hooked. Yes. And at least when you rented it, you can probably watch it a few times in a row because you just pick up on so many things. I think it probably took me a couple of watches before I evenâ realize in the beginning that Keaton actually says Kaiser's name was like, how did I not hear this before? I mean, it's just so subtle and it was so there and I felt so dumb.
4:47 I'm like, how did I miss this? Like, I don't, I don't know. I was just so transfixed on, Hey, there's this guy that's obviously, you know, his fate is sealed. And I, I remember it was a big pop culture type of thing. Like, you know, it was almost kind of a joke where people were saying, You heard people saying, who is Kaiser Soze? It was like almost like a saying before you even saw the movie. Yeah. I remember seeing it like on maybe like a collage of like pop culture stuff for like the year. And that was like one of the big things on there. But yeah, it's brilliant and a brilliant screenplay. Yes. And so we'll then get into our writer's background. So Christopher McQuarrie and Bryan Singer were longtime friends who first collaborated on a film, Public Access, which shared the grand jury prize at the 1993 Sundance Film Festival. Their next project began with a title and an image. Five criminals standing in a police lineup. The title came from a spy magazine column referencing Captain Reynolds' famous instruction to round up the usual suspects in Casablanca. Singer then posed the question that launched the story. What could bring five career criminals together in the same lineup? McQuarrie combined that concept with an earlier idea about a man who murders his own family and disappears. That story became the foundation for the Kaiser Soze legend. The screenplay went through nine drafts over approximately five months. Partway through the writing process, McQuarrie proposed
6:17 that the villain construct his story from objects inside the interrogation room, giving the screenplay its famous bulletin board revelation. Its non-linear structure, heavy dialogue, and lack of major stars made the project difficult to finance. Nearly every studio rejected it. Tentative European financing allowed the filmmakers to begin finally assembling the cast. Although that financing did collapse, the actors remained committed. Armed with both a highly regarded screenplay and an impressive ensemble, the filmmakers finally persuaded Polygram to. Pick up the usual suspects. Angela, the The screenplay, you know, with the image of the five criminals and a lot of how effective and gutsy, I guess it is to build an entire story around just one strong visual idea.
7:04 It's pretty gutsy. But like you said, when you have five career criminals and these guys aren't stupid, you put them in a room and usually, you know, anything else, you know, that we tend to watch and even, you. Know, TV shows. they're not, it's usually one will always kind. Of stick out, but all of these guys got to stick out with that. So, and like you said, how do you get these kinds of guys in the same room? And there's gotta be someone up on high, whether it be from, you know, within the system or another criminal, you know, mastermind being a little, you know, puppeteer and manipulative, you know, magic and getting them together for, there's a reason.
7:52 Yeah. We just don't know what that is, but that, but it is a very impactful image. Um, and I can honestly say like when I first saw the cover in, uh, when I was working at the video store. I kind of thought it could have gone both ways. This could be a super serious movie or is this just one of those goofball, not goofball, but, um, like a spoof type thing where it was going to be more of like, is this more going to be like a comedy heist? Yeah. I could see that scene looking at the picture at first, you know, a lot of the stuff in the eighties and early nineties kind of had that thing. Yeah. So, but obviously it was definitely more of the serious, serious nature. I mean, yeah, no, I love the cover.
8:34 I mean, that's great. I mean, I think it works here, not just, and it has become iconic because like you said, you take five criminals and you put them in a lineup. Well, then your mind can go anywhere. Yeah. We can make one really lethal. We can make one weird. I mean, so you can do. So I think with something like this, it can be done. You know, it's not going to be done all the time, but I think it I think it worked really well there. And and we know that image. I think it's even like Bryan Singer's bad hat Harry image for his like it comes up and it's just the silhouette of all them. I'm like, that's perfect. Yeah, absolutely. And it's a little bit, you know, the title is ironic because even though, you know, usual, I.
9:18 Feel like these guys are a little bit more of the top tier, you know, type criminals. So I guess it's a matter of perspective as to, you know, what you would consider usual, but not just these run-of-the-mill just criminals. Maybe the usual suspects, question mark. Yes. Yeah. Like there's a dot, dot, dot there. Well, we're going to take our first quick break, but when we come back, we will unravel the first 10 pages in Act 1 of The Usual Suspects. Welcome back to a script by We Are Talking, Kristen McQuarrie's The Usual Suspect and the first 10 pages in Act 1. So let's get started with the first 10 pages. The screenplay opens aboard a ship where a badly injured Dean Keaton attempts to ignite a trail of gasoline. An unidentified man extinguishes the fire, shoots Keaton, and destroys the ship.
10:11 Now McQuarrie conceals the killer's face but emphasizes a gold watch and an unusual antique lighter operated with a fluid, somewhat showy motion. These initially appear to be character details, but they will eventually become important evidence. Keaton recognizes the man and calls him Kaiser. With more than 20 bodies scattered across the pier, we know that a massacre has occurred and that Kaiser Soze is apparently responsible. What we don't know is who he is, what happened aboard the ship, or how Keaton became involved. The story then moves back six weeks to New York, guided by the voice of Roger Verbal Kint. Following the hijacking of truck-carrying gun parts, several career criminals are arrested. McManus responds with sarcasm, Hockney with humor, and Fenster attempts to run. Keaton receives the most attention. He's trying to leave crime behind and enter the restaurant business with the support of his attorney and girlfriend, Edie Finneran. That effort is disrupted when Special Agent Dave Koyan arrests him in front of his potential investors. By page 10, McQuarrie has established the players and the central mysteries.
11:19 Why were these particular men brought together? Is Keaton truly reformed? Who is Kaiser Soze? And can we trust the man telling us the story? Angela, the screenplay shows us Keaton's death before introducing this life he's trying to build. How does knowing his fate shape the way you view him? I found it maybe a bit empathetic because you can just tell by the look on his face that whatever has gone bad, was by someone he knew and perhaps, you know, trusted. Um, so there's like been a double cross that you think, but winds up being way more than that. Um, and then going through the movie, seeing that, you know, he really did try, uh, but you know, like they say, you know, leopard can't change its spots.
12:09 Right. And he's kind of, you know, I think all the guys kind of realize that, there is no way out of this life. No, no, no. But death, but death. Cause either, even if. There was no Kaiser, so say you'd still have the police, they're constantly harassing you. And, and automatically that is going to block you from anybody wanting to do business with a queer criminal, you know, like that. And, or as Kuhan called it, like the hooker with a heart of gold story, you know, type thing. But definitely, you know, empathetic and interested of like what kind of deal went down to basically, you know, he was ready to just let himself go out, but then was stopped.
13:01 Yeah. And he, you know, Kaiser could have just let it happen. But no, it's like he wanted him to know who he was and then be the one to to actually. I actually do. Now, at this point, who do you think the screenplay wants us to trust? And is there anyone you're already suspicious of for the first time? Well, I think with Verbal Kent, we get that sympathy because he is physically disabled. And you feel like he's... You know, Bitslow doesn't. Really have anything. You know, anybody else kind of going, and this is the life. This is the only thing he has. And so... it's like you want to believe him, but then at the same point, that makes him a little bit more suspicious of that.
13:49 So, I mean, for me, you, you want to trust Keaton, the things you hear about him. Yeah. Yes. And you look at, okay, Gabriel Byrne, it's really hard to picture him doing the things that he is accused of doing from his past. So seeing him, I did, it's, or just, I guess just the way it's written is, is very easy for me to trust him right away, but it's also easy for me to be, he could be running things. You know, so. Right. And, and having, you know, the Edie Fetter, sorry, if I'm saying the last name of the character wrong. Edie Finneran. Finneran.
14:29 Um, you know, having her, I mean, obviously she's put together, she's not a dummy and, um, and despite knowing his previous life, obviously she has gotten to know other sides of him that, you know, we don't see, but that she has worked really hard to try to support him and try to help him in, you know, you know. That change of life. And I feel, I feel like he was sincere in that. I don't think he was, you know, really, you know, using her or anything like that. You do feel like there was that genuine want there, but then like you said, did, Nature will always take kind of, you know, over and, you know, what you truly are is still kind of, you know, going to be there.
15:14 So, yeah. So having that supportive person be there does make you, oh, hey, there's other sides to him and maybe we can trust him. And, you know, he he really is trying to do this, but then gets to the point where he kind of has no choice. I think he knows if he loses her. Yeah, he he's got to go back. So that's his last little thing. Like his Hail Mary to try to have a normal life. But even though even he doesn't believe he's ever going to have a normal life, you know, so. All right. Let's open up Act One, rounding up the usual suspects. Now, the hijacked gun truck triggers the investigation. But the true inciting incident is the police lineup that brings the five criminals together. Vermal summarizes the police apparent mistake.
16:03 You don't put. Guys like that in a room together. Inside the holding cell, McManus proposes robbing the New York's finest taxi service, a group of corrupt officers who transport smugglers and drug dealers throughout the city. Keaton refuses because another crime could destroy the legitimate life he is building with Edie. The screenplay then returns to the present. Verbal has received immunity following the Harbor Massacre, while Special Agent Kuyon arrives determined to discover what happened to Keaton. Elsewhere, a badly burned Hungarian survivor repeatedly names Kaiser Soze, and claims that he has seen the devil. Kuyon begins the interrogation already convinced that Keaton never truly changed. This gives Verbal a weakness to exploit.
16:47 Kuyon isn't searching for the truth, as much as he is searching for evidence that confirms what he already believes. Back in New York, the. Lineup has damaged Keaton's restaurant proposal and convinced him that the police may never allow him to escape his past. Verbal then visits Keaton and pressures him to join the robbery. He claims that the others need Keaton, but Verbal has already created a plan that will prevent anyone from being killed. He appears to need Keaton's protection, but he is actually using Keaton's anger toward the police to pull him into the crime. Keaton finally agrees, and the five men successfully rob the taxi service without killing anyone. Which is a great scene, by the way. Oh, yeah. And they expose the corrupt police operation as well. Afterwards, the others celebrate around a table covered with stolen embers and praise Verbal as... My boy with the plan. Another clue thrown out there. Keaton will sit apart, recognizing he has returned to the life that he wanted to escape.
17:42 Now to sell these emeralds, the group agrees to go to travel to California and meet a criminal contact named Redfoot. Before leaving, Keaton attempts to see Edie one final time. But Verbal reminds him that they're going to be late and miss their flight. That choice then completes Act 1. Keaton begins the story preparing for a legitimate future with Edie. He ends returning to crime and following Verbal to Los Angeles. Keaton may appear to be the group's leader, but the least threatening man among them is already directing the story. Do you believe the police. Drive Keaton back into crime or does Verbal use their harassment as the pressure point he needs? I think Verbal definitely manipulates that pressure point and just kind of driving home that like you said the police are never gonna leave him alone I mean even Keaton when he's on the steps with with Edie outside the restaurant he's like it's just never gonna stop he's never gonna stop you know and and so I think Verbal heavily uses that um.
18:46 You know exploits that to get him in. And also trying to gain his sympathy like hey the other guys won't let me in without you right you know he kept you know saying you know so um like you know like you said was that really true but you know Keaton was definitely you know was a very much needed piece in order for Verbal to carry out his his plan. And those little lines like after he punches him you know I'm gonna shit blood tonight you. Know and it's like and then they kind of share a giggle oh. Man I'm sorry okay I'll do. The thing with you definitely a little bit of a guilt. Yeah I mean he plays his strings very very well yes You know, but the thing, though, is that I think originally the plan was supposed to be McManus's.
19:38 Then it just turns into Verbal's plan. Right. Yes, because he was the one who brought the idea, like, while they were all together, because Keaton was like, I don't want anything to do with it. Yeah. And I don't. Believe in the jail cell that they even talk about the taxi service job. They're just talking about a job. No, they were just a job, yeah. Well, we're going to take our second and final break, and when we come back, we're going to dive into Act 2 and 3 of The Usual Suspect. Welcome back to A Script By. We have covered the first 10 pages in Act 1 of The Usual Suspects. Now we jump to Act 2. Enter Kaiser Soze. Act 2 begins when the group arrives in Los Angeles to sell the stolen emeralds through Redfoot. Redfoot offers them another robbery, but the job goes wrong. McManus kills two bodyguards, and when Keaton hesitates, Verbal shoots their target, Saul. That moment changes our understanding of Verbal. The supposedly helpless member of the group is capable of killing without warning.
20:38 And a hell of a shot, too. Yes. Saul's briefcase also contains drugs instead of expected valuables, revealing that the men had been manipulated and committing murder. Redfoot claims that the job came from a lawyer whom Verbal identifies as Kobayashi. Kobayashi reveals that all five men have unknowingly stolen from Kaiser Sozei. and that Soze arranged the original police lineup to bring them together. What appeared to be the inciting incident is now revealed as the first stage of a larger plan. So to repay their debts, the men must attack a ship in the San Pedro Harbor and destroy a cocaine shipment. The screenplay's central motivation changes. They're no longer committing crimes for revenge or benefit. They're fighting for their survival. Verbal then tells Kuyon the legend of Kaiser Soze. Whether the story is true matters.
21:28 Less than its effect. Jose stops feeling like an ordinary criminal and becomes an almost supernatural force, capable of controlling events without appearing. Fenster attempts to run and is murdered, eliminating escape as any kind of option. The others confront Kobayashi, hoping to regain control, but he reveals that Edie and their other loved ones are being watched. They cannot run, refuse the job, or kill the messengers. Every action in Act 2 reduces their freedom until the harbor becomes their only possible destination. As they prepare for the attack, Keaton cannot locate the cocaine they were sent to destroy. That missing piece redirects the mystery going into Act 3. If the job isn't really about drugs, what or who does Kaiser Soze need eliminated aboard the ship? By the end of Act 2, Soze appears to be controlling their lives. What they don't realize is that he's already standing among them controlling the story.
22:27 So every option is gradually just removed from the group. They can't run. They can't refuse the jobs. They can't kill Kobayashi. How does that tightening, that structure affect the tension? I mean, these guys are being bottlenecked and just every time they get closer to, especially to that ship. And you, I think you ultimately know that they are all going into their death. And I think they all know that too, but it's still, you want to know who is behind all this. What is up with the customs? Like you said, who or what is going, you know, is on this shipment and what's, why is this such a big deal? And, you know, and so important, you know, the, can't and they don't you know don't trust the cops they all have records everything you know basically you know.
23:16 Being blackmailed and like you said it. They apparently stole from kaiser so they owe him um and then you know you do kind of wonder is anybody going to make it out of this but yeah um so it just makes that you know all that tension of just there's so many everything with every scene, it's just, there's more, you know, more, more questions to be had. And you're like, what the heck is going on here? And who is doing all of this? Yeah. So it keeps you interested. Yeah. And the fact that, I mean, they've got every tiny little detail that they've ever done. No, every single detail about pieces of their family.
23:56 Yes. And I think it's this for even the, the, the remaining four is this curiosity to know who the hell is this guy? Right. We're going to do this. It's like this guy knows things that the cops probably don't even know. Yeah. I think they want to get the job done just so they can try to confront Kaiser Soze and kill him. Right. Completely being blinded to like. Exactly. Or at least know who it is. The devil walks among us. Yes. To see if he's real or not. Yes. Yeah. Well, it's time for act three. The man behind the story. Act three sends the remaining four men to the San Pedro Harbor. Keaton has been unable to confirm that any cocaine is aboard the ship, but Soze has eliminated every alternative.
24:41 The men proceed with the attack because their lives and their lives of their family depend on it. The operation begins like the violent climax of a heist film, but the promised drug transaction is a deception. Hockney and McManus are killed while Keaton searches the ship without finding any cocaine. The true target is a witness aboard the ship who can identify Kaiser Soze. The entire operation has been designed to eliminate him and everyone else who might connect Soze to his death. The unknown killer murders the witness and confronts Keaton. According to Verbal, he watches from a hiding place as the man shoots Keaton and destroys the ship. The physical climax does not solve the mystery. Instead, the screenplay returns to the interrogation room where Kuyon attempts to give Verbal's story a clear ending. And after learning there were no drugs aboard the ship, Kuyon concludes that Keaton was Sozay. He believes Keaton used the other men to reach the witness, faked his death, and left Verbal alive to tell the authorities exactly what he wanted him to hear.
25:41 The theory fits Kuyon's belief that Keaton never changed. Verbal breaks down and finally agrees that Keaton controlled everything, allowing Kuyon to believe he has solved the case. But this is the screenplay's false resolution. After Verbal leaves, Kuyon recognizes pieces of his story on the bulletin board. And coffee cup. Redfoot. Bricks Marlin, a barbershop quartet in Skokie, and the name Kobayashi. Verbal wasn't struggling to remember the past. He was constructing a story from objects around him and shaping it around Kuyon's obsession with Keaton. Outside, Verbal's limp disappears, his disabled hand regains its coordination, and he operates the same antique lighter used by Keaton's killer. At the same time, the composite sketch of Soze arrives, and it resembles Verbal. The boat attack, Kuyon's theory, and Verbal's escape form three climaxes.
26:31 Physical action, a false solution, and finally, the truth. The reveal identifies Verbal as Soze, but creates a larger mystery about how much of the story was real. Kuyon loses because he mistakes a satisfying explanation for the correct one. The screenplay begins by hiding Soze's face. It ends by revealing that we've been looking directly at him and listening to him control the story the entire time. So does the ending answer the central mystery or replace it with more interesting questions about what was real? Definitely replaces more questions about what is real. Even this time around.
27:12 Yeah. Oh, yeah, absolutely. You know, just having a fresh rewatch. And I'm like, I'm still like, who the hell is Kaiser Soze? You know, it's like, did he really do that to his family? I'm like, dang. I mean, if not, that's a pretty dagged story of, you know, him trying to show his will, you know, that he would kill his own family before allowing, you know, them to be killed, you know, by was that Hungarian gang, I believe, that had come into his, if I remember. Yeah. Um, yeah, because he's supposed to be Turkish, right? Yes. Yeah. Well, that's what he said. Yes. Yes. So again, part of that. Yeah.
27:53 Yes. What is that true? I, you know, or is he just so caught up in just the secret and anything that maybe even, you know, he doesn't quite remember what his origin story is, too. He's just so. So deep in it so he doesn't have to, you know. You can go down a giant rabbit hole with this one. Whoever recounts whatever is just going to lead everybody into another dead end. I mean, it could be Soze is just an organization or a name they made up. Right. It could be him. The boogeyman, Krampus. Yeah, I mean. It's just right up there. So many things. And then you're like, okay, what portions of the story did I watch? Do I know were real? And what portions. Right. You know, were made up.
28:34 You know, you can at least know for truth the police line up, the death on the harbors and stuff like that, but there's a lot of stuff in the middle. But I think a lot of it, it was a lot true because there's no reason for Verbal to kind of make all that crap up. Right. Yeah, it was like, it doesn't, but it helps his story. Absolutely. And then while you have him recounting his many variations, then you got. Agent Kuhans. He already, like you said, he has his answer in his head and he's trying to bend the evidence and everything to fit that versus the other way around. So then you've got following his story, Right.
29:27 Right. That's also a bit distracting too, because he's, he's come to a conclusion, but without the support of it, he's just trying to make it all fit them because he's got such. A, for lack of a better phrase, hard on for Keaton. Yeah. He wants it to be all kind of like, man, I'm like, what? So he can say, I knew it. I knew it the entire time. Right. Yeah. I mean, it was like, what, what exactly is all in Keaton's back? And I was really just such a crow in your butt, you know? So, So he definitely has a bit of a personal vendetta against this guy too, which interferes with his job. I think it is probably affected his career in a very negative way. It's made him look foolish at times and he's just not going to take his hand down, you know, it's just, but yeah, I mean, you can, you can come up with so many theories at the end of this film of what you think is real, but that's.
30:25 What's great about it. Yeah. And a big giveaway where you know that he's, either wrong or he's just really going to look like a fool. Anytime I feel like, you know, a cop or investigator gets so super cocky where they get right up in, you know, the witness's face. I'm smarter than you and I know this and the figure. I'm like, oh my God, you are going to be proven so wrong and it's going to be so spectacular that you deserve it for being such an asshat at your job and, you know, you're not really good at it if this is how. You know, you play. Yeah. So right off the bat, as soon as he starts spouting that off, I'm like, oh, this, he's so wrong about everything.
31:05 I don't know exactly how it's going to play out, but I know this guy's wrong. Yeah. I mean, he's been obviously chasing him for years. And he wants him so badly that, yeah, he will put every, you know, critical thinking skill, every logic looks, everything just doesn't matter. It's just, he's just so focused and narrow minded on this that he's just got blinders on everything else. Yeah. Well, that's going to close out Act 1, Act 2, and Act 3 of The Usual Suspects. Now, it is time to go beyond the page. First up, foreshadowing, symbols, and setup. Now, we'll go beyond the story and examine how McQuarrie prepares us for the final reveal, though foreshadowing, symbolism, and setup pay off. The most direct foreshadowing appears in the opening. Keaton's killer carries a gold watch and an antique gold lighter. which he operates with fluid, somewhat showy motion, which it says in the screenplay. At the end, Verbal collects a gold watch and lighter from the police. He operates the lighter with the same distinctive movement, transforming an apparent character detail into physical evidence connecting him to Keaton's killer.
32:17 McQuarrie also introduces Verbal through his voice before showing us his face. His first observation is, sometimes that's all you need. The line refers to a truck driver identifying a hijacker by his voice, but it also foreshadows Verbal's greatest weapon, his voice, and his ability to tell a convincing story is all he needs to control Kulian. Other clues appear in Verbal's behavior. He recruits Keaton, creates the taxi service plan, and shoots Saul when Keaton hesitates. Redfoot even calls him the man with the plan. These actions challenge Verbal's helpless persona. but the story directs our attention toward Keaton.
32:58 As the group's leader. One especially revealing action line appears when Keaton agrees to the robbery. Verbal smiles, knowing he has him. Initially, Verbal has simply won an argument. After the reveal, it becomes the moment when Soze successfully pulls Keaton back into the crime. Hands and feet also symbolize identity. Soze is introduced through fragments of his body while Verbal's twisted hand and limp define him as harmless. At the end, those same hands and feet transform, exposing the identity he has been performing. The bulletin board and the coffee cup symbolize the construction of Verbal's narrative. They contain disconnected pieces of information that he arranges into a coherent story. Verbal mentions a barbershop in Quartet and Scocoy, Redfoot, Bricks, Marlin. Only afterward do we discover that those details came from the objects surrounding him.
33:51 The Hungarian survivor creates another setup. While Verbal is being questioned, the survivor is helping the police create a sketch of Soze. This establishes a deadline the audience doesn't recognize. Verbal must be released before the sketch arrives. Even Kujan's personality becomes part of this setup. His certainty that Keaton never changed allows Verbal to construct a story leading him toward the conclusion he already wants. The final reveal works because it doesn't introduce new information. It changes the meaning of information we have already received. McQuarrie hides the truth, not by withholding the clues, but giving us a narrator who tells us how to interpret them. Which piece of the foreshadowing feels the fairest to you once the truth is revealed?
34:39 Definitely the gold watch and the gold lighter. I mean, those are details that, you know, you can see on the killer without seeing his face. You have his voice, um, But yeah, when he goes and picks it up, you're like, didn't Kaiser Soce have that too in the beginning? But also I wanted to mention, because they do a close-up, I believe at least twice, of the stack of ropes on the pier. And you think that somebody. Because Verbal is saying that he was hiding and he saw everything, that that is assuming that there is someone there. Behind that watching. And usually through that, you can see like a glint of eyes, you know, but there is absolutely nothing.
35:23 Yeah. So if you don't take that for granted and just, you know, oh, well, maybe I just didn't, you know, see it. Uh, but you're meant to believe that someone was behind there, but there wasn't. So if you, um, you know, stick with your instincts and, and believe your eyes, uh, then you know, that verbal story is BS from the get go. Um, that there was no, you know, there wasn't anybody there, but we're misdirected and shown that, um, you know, stationary pile of ropes to believe that somebody was, uh, to add to the story. And then when you realize, okay, yeah, no, he, yeah. And just like, like you just even mentioned it, like thinking about it now and I'm like, okay, there just sounds like.
36:04 We're showing you this, but we're not showing you that there's anybody behind you. We're just showing you this. And he even zooms in. Yeah. It's almost like telling you, there's no one there. Right. There's no one there. But just, you know, kind of thing. That's what's just so great about it. All right. Dialogue and subtext. Now, dialogue is one of the screenplay's greatest strengths. Yes. McQuarrie gives each character a distinctive voice while using verbal words to conceal a different story. Beneath the one being told. The lineup and interactions establish the suspects through speech. McManus is aggressive and theatrical. Hockney is blunt and sarcastic. And Fenster's unusual rhythm makes him immediately recognizable.
36:51 Yes. What do you say in English? You gotta watch this one with subtitles. Yes. Well, interesting bit, just a little tangent that I had read that apparently when they're each reading that, the line in the line up, When somebody is saying in English, please, apparently that was Bryan Singer. I guess that was like ad-libbed and it just fed into him. Like, what do you mean? And he just kept playing into it, you know, with that. And then they all kind of were cracking up laughing. Yeah. Because it wasn't English. We just couldn't understand him.
37:34 But Keaton, though, Keaton speaks with greater control, reflecting both his authority and and his effort to separate himself from the other criminals. Verbal's name becomes a joke hidden in plain sight. He explains, Roger, really? People say I talk too much. The others treat his talking as a weakness, but it is actually his greatest source of power. He survives by controlling what other people hear and believe. The central dialogue battle occurs between Verbal and Kuyon. Kuyon believes intimidation will reveal the truth. He tells Verbal, I'm smarter than you. The subtext is the opposite. Kuyon's need to prove his intelligence makes him very vulnerable. Once Verbal recognizes his obsession with Keaton, he creates a story that allows Kuyon to believe he solved the mystery himself. Verbal rarely tells him what to believe directly. He hesitates, he appears frightened, and leaves gaps that Kuyon fills. The interrogation sounds like Kuyon forcing information out of Verbal, but Verbal is quietly directing the conversation. Verbo's repeated question, whose Kaiser Soze, is another performance. On the surface, he appears unfamiliar with Soze.
38:43 Beneath the dialogue, Soze is encouraging the other men to describe and strengthen the myths surrounding him. Kobayashi uses dialogue differently, too. He remains formal and polite while threatening the men and their families. His restraint makes him more intimidating because he doesn't need to raise his voice. Every act of resistance has already been anticipated. During the final interrogation, Verbal appears to break down and says, it was all Keaton. We followed him from the beginning. Kuyon hears a confession. In reality, Verbal is giving him the ending he wants. Throughout the screenplay, characters say one thing while pursuing another objective. Kuyon appears to be searching for truth, but wants confirmation. Verbal appears to be confessing, but is protecting his identity. Kobayashi appears to offer a choice after every alternative has been removed.
39:31 Once we know the truth, Verbal's dialogue changes completely. His fear becomes reformance, his confusion becomes improvisation, and his confession becomes the final stage of his escape. McQuarrie doesn't hide Soze by keeping him silent. He hides him by allowing him to do most of the talking. Does Verbal's defeat of Kuhian, does he beat him with better information or by understanding who he is? I would have to say maybe a little bit of both because, I mean, obviously with him being. Basically the master puppeteer, I mean, he already has all of. The information, but the knowing Kuhian's obsession with Keaton and making him the perfect.
40:17 fall guy for him. He definitely, you know, exploits that. So, I mean, it's... I don't really think, like, really one is more than the other. I feel like he uses both. Yeah, I think he uses Keon's hatred of Keaton more. You know, he just seems to, you know, listing down, you know, when he says, like, you know, the guy I knew was one mean son of a bitch. Right. You know. and, you know, saying all these things about him. So, and he almost, like you said, he fills in the gaps. He wants it to be Keaton. He's, he's pushing for it, you know? And so it, he's doing verbal job for him.
41:03 Right. It's like, here, here's a mad lib. Just, he fell right into it. You know? Yeah. Yeah. A lot of the stuff he's, you know, making, yeah, he's making up the stuff, but it's not that he has the better story is that, I mean, even at that final breakdown. It was all him. It seems forced. Right. I mean, he, you're like. He knew he wanted it to be him. Like the entire, it's like, who did not hide that at all? Um, I mean, if anything, it would be like misleading the witness in a way, um, with that. So it's like how much of that testimony or that interrogation would, you. Know, because it would be helpful for anything. Um, right and it.
41:47 Wasn't even though right um but just you know it just happened a conversation yeah but you just you you know in his own way he kind of was trying to control the narrative and and verbal just played on into. It and in a way he kind of did one more kind of you know middle finger to kuyon oh absolutely i'm gonna make you look like a fool again even in my. Right Yeah, so good luck explaining this to. When they say, what. Do you mean you've had him in there for like three hours or whatever? Oh, absolutely. So yeah, he's going to be going on a bender and. Oh yeah, he's dying. Even off a bridge, yeah.
42:29 Well, let's get into page versus screen. Now, the finished film follows McQuarrie's screenplay remarkably closely. Its nonlinear structure, major character turns... and final revelation are already present on the page. The screen version strengthens that material through performance, editing, and visual misdirection. One of the clearest examples is the lineup. The screenplay presents the suspects as confrontational and individually distinct, but the actors' difficulty remaining serious gave the film scene an unexpected looseness. Their laughter creates an immediate sense of camaraderie and makes it believable that these men could eventually work together. Benicio Del Toro also transformed Fenster. His distinctive speech pattern was not written as we hear it in the film, and some dialogue was redistributed between Fenster and McManus to fit the actor's personalities. Their functions remain the same, but the performances make the group feel less calculated and more unpredictable. Another change occurs when Verbal convinces Keaton to join the taxi service robbery. In this draft, Keaton agrees and says, I swore I'd live above myself. The finished film ends the exchange earlier, with Keaton asking, no killing, and Verbo responding, not if we do it my way.
43:44 McQuarrie later acknowledged that the shorter version works better. Rather than explaining Keaton's conflict, Gabriel Byrne's performance allows us to see it. The film trusts the actor to communicate what the screenplay states directly. The greatest translation from page to screen occurs during the final reveal. On the page, McQuarrie can explicitly describe Kuyon, recognizing names from the bulletin board. Verbal's limp disappearing and the composite sketch resembling him. The film must make those connections visually and emotionally. During editing, the filmmakers reportedly felt that the reveal delivered the information, but lacked the necessary impact. Editor John Ottman created a rapid montage combining the bulletin board, images from earlier scenes, and overlapping dialogue. That montage allows us to experience Kuyon's realization with him. We don't simply learn that Verbal fabricated his story. We suddenly remember the moments when he was doing it directly in front of us. Kevin Spacey's physical performance completes the transformation. Verbal's foot straightens, his limp disappears, and his disabled hand regains its coordination before he operates the antique lighter. The story remains largely unchanged between page and screen. What changes is how the deception reaches us.
45:01 McQuarrie controls it on the page through description, withheld information, and point of view. The film adds performance, framing, sound, and editing. The screenplay gives us the trick. The finished film makes us feel its effect. So would the final reveal be as powerful without the rapid montage and images overlapping the dialogue? No, absolutely not. I agree. That whole thing, like you said, you're realizing it as is, yes. It is a. Slap in the face. Hole no yeah if it would have been so flat and you'd have been like that's okay but yeah having that all like you said it's all coming back oh yeah these are all these things hiding in plain sight it was all right there in.
45:46 Front of us and he was like oh yeah i mean and i wanted to see how it it's so it. Doesn't read as exciting on the page right it does but it's it's it's Yeah. I mean, it's all there. You know, he gets the hand back, you know, he slips and he says, you know, does the lighter in the fluid showy way and. Stuff like that. But yeah, it is that editing that gives you that gasp. Oh, absolutely. Like we, what movie were we just watching? Right. Yeah. No. Yeah, exactly. And now the moment that defines the script. The moment that defines the usual suspect is Verbal's story about the origins of Kaiser Soze. When Kuyon asks who Soze is, Verbal describes a Turkish criminal whose family was taken hostage by a Hungarian gang. Rather than surrender, Soze kills his own family and then destroys everyone connected to his enemies.
46:47 Verbal explains that power does not necessarily come from. Guns, money, or numbers. It comes from possessing the will to do whatever the other guy wouldn't. Whether the story is true remains deliberately uncertain. It may be history, criminal folklore, or something Verbal invents to transform Soze into a myth, but its effect is undeniable. After this scene, Soze no longer feels like an ordinary criminal. He becomes an almost supernatural force capable of controlling people through fear. This moment defines the screenplay because Verbal is doing more than delivering exposition. He is using storytelling to shape how Kuyan and the audience understand Soze. He then delivers the screenplay's defining line, the greatest trick the devil ever pulled was convincing the world he didn't exist. That line explains Soze's method while Verbal performs the trick directly in front of us. He presents himself as weak, frightened, and insignificant. The more terrifying he makes Soze sound, the more impossible it seems that Verbal could be that man.
47:52 The story also reveals Soze's philosophy. He survives by sacrificing every relationship, identity, or piece of evidence that can make him vulnerable. Even the identity of Verbal Kent disappears once it has served its purpose. The final reveal shows us who Soze is, but this scene tells us. How he wins. He understands what people fear, gives them a story that explains that fear, and allows the story to become more powerful than the man behind it. Soze does not simply hide inside the story, he creates it. So do you believe that Verbal is telling us Soze's real history or is he creating this legend? And does the scene become more powerful because we never really.
48:35 Know for certain? Definitely becomes more powerful because, yeah, you don't know what to believe. It's like you wouldn't put it past him. But I think that kind of an origin story. I don't know. I think it's more smoke and mirrors. I think it's a very good story and it's a very interesting story as far as demonstrating, yeah, the will to do what others wouldn't, which you just murdered your own family so that the game wouldn't do it. Or just what a power play of like, you think you can get me? No, look at this. I'm going to wipe out my whole family. What can you do to me? You know, kind of a thing.
49:16 And then going after, you know, everybody and their family and their nieces and nephews and probably the animals, um, uh, not the animals. Um, so who knows what, what. Really was, but I think a lot of it is just like you said, it just feeds into like that, you know, that boogeyman that, you know, the bleakening type of thing. And And you can never know for certain, but would you want to test it? Yeah. You know, it's like, you know what? I'm just going to err on the side of caution. And then we're just going to say that. Yeah, that happened. You know? Yeah. I mean, I'm sure we would love, I'm not going to Kaiser Soze the movie or the prequel. Oh yeah. I mean, even I was thinking that again after the rewatch is like, how have we not gotten this movie yet?
50:01 Are you listening to us? I know. How do we not have this movie? But yeah, I just, I, I, I think even if it is fabricated, it's such a great story. Oh, yeah. It's too good to not be convincing that this guy's bad news. Right. And how can you fact check a story like that? Yeah. Turkish, Hungarian gangs. In New York? Who would tell you? And especially if he wiped out everybody, or even if he didn't, it's like, who's going to talk to you about. That guy, you know, like you didn't know. Hell no.
50:41 Shutting doors, locking windows. You know, exactly. There is no way you can never get to the bottom of that anyway. Yeah. Well, now it's time for legacy and lessons. The usual suspect transformed Christopher McQuarrie from a relatively unknown screenwriter into an Academy Award winner. The screenplay won both the Academy Award and the BAFTA for best original screenplay. In 2006, the Writers Guild of America ranked it number 35 on its list of the 101 greatest screenplays. Its legacy, however, is not simply that it contains a memorable twist. The ending works because the revelation changes the meaning of the story rather than replacing it. Macquarie gives us essential facts from the beginning. Keaton is killed.
51:25 Verbal survives. Soze is connected to the massacre and five criminals were deliberately brought together. The deception comes from how Verbal arranges those facts and directs our attention toward Keaton. That leads to the first lesson. A twist should be built on information the audience has already received. The gold lighter, watch, false disability, bulletin board, and Verbal's control over the group are all established before the reveal. The ending is surprising, but it does not come from nowhere. The second lesson is that misdirection works best when it is based on character. Verbal studies Kuyon and gives him the story he already wants to believe. Kuyon's certainty that Keaton never changed becomes the flaw that prevents him from recognizing Soze directly in front of him. Finally, an unreliable narrator should create uncertainty without making the entire story meaningless. If Verbal's complete account were proven false, the ending would feel like a cheat. Instead, the screenplay gives us enough independently confirmed events to know that the massacre lineup, and Soze's operation were real. The uncertainty comes from the names, motivations, and relationships, verbal places around those events. That uncertainty is one reason the screenplay continues to invite discussion. The ending answers the question, who is Kaiser Soze, but leaves us with another, how much of his story was true? The greatest lesson of The Usual Suspect is that the audience do not merely follow facts.
52:56 We follow the meanings a storyteller gives them. And if the storyteller understands what we want to believe, he can hide the truth directly in front of us. Does knowing the ending improve the screenplay on a second reading or does it reduce the power of the mystery? I think it improves it. I don't think it takes away. If anything, it provides a great appreciation for those layers and hitting all those points without, like you said, not feeling cheated or you know, or, you know, like a cop-out ending or something not so obvious, but yet. The clues were there. You know, a bunch of little Easter.
53:37 Eggs that you can go, oh, but that's what makes that story so great. But still leaving, wondering, you know, how much of this was all true, even though the kind of the more important thing needs have been met, you know, from the film, you know, and definitely not disappointing. So I think it just provides a greater appreciation for how that all came together without being so obvious and being very intelligently done. Well, one thing I do hope is true is that I hope it was Hockney that took the truck of guns. Yes. Because when they go, when he's like, took a truck and they all look over and he's just like, Yeah, it was me.
54:22 I love that. Yeah. So we can kind of blame this on him. Yeah. Yeah. That was you. He's like, what are you going to do? Yeah. You, you messed up. And, you know, and speaking of like Kevin Pollak being in that serious role, I was only used to kind of seeing him and like, Oh yeah. Like, you know, grumpy old men and grumpy old men and those, you know, low key type of things. And, uh, not low key. I didn't mean like that, but more, uh, light, I guess light is what I meant. Um, and then seeing him like in this, it was interesting. I'm like, you know what? I kind of want to see Kevin, Kevin Paul. It's a great ensemble. Yeah. Oh no. It was a great ensemble. It was very, very good. Uh, you know, very well done.
55:04 Gabriel Burnham. He's just amazing. Whatever he does. So, um, but yes, great, great cast. If yeah. Along with this, the story, the, the reveal, the, yeah, the satisfaction of all of that. Great cast. Yeah. You get a smile on your face after watching it. You're like, oh, that was, you're like, that was worth my time. Oh, absolutely. Oh yeah. Totally was. And then just the way it ends. And then just like that, he's gone. I mean, it's so, it's just so good because that part, you know, it's true. Yeah. You're, you're, you're never going to hear from this guy. Yeah. So you, you know what the important things, you. Know, what, what truths that matter, but others, you're just like, You know, it's okay if I don't know. I mean, it would be an interesting, you know, Kaiser Soze origin story.
55:53 But, you know, it's okay. You never know. It's right. Well, before we close things out, it is time for our companion picks. Now, my companion pick for the usual suspects is 1950s Akira Kurosawa's Rashomon. Now, the film presents several conflicting accounts of the same violent event. Each person describes a version that protects their pride, shifts responsibility, or presents them in a more favorable light. Instead of identifying one account as completely truthful, the film forces us to question whether objective truth can never ever be recovered from personal testimony. That makes it an ideal companion to the usual suspects. Verbal gives us only one version of what happened, but this account gives different levels of the truth. The massacre occurred, the five criminals were brought together, and someone aboard the ship could identify Soze. The names, conversations, motivations, and Verbal's role in those events may have been altered.
56:49 The major difference in Rashomon gives us several unreliable narrators whose story contradict one another. If the usual suspects leaves you wondering how much of Verbal's story was true, try Rashomon. You might like it. What do you got for your companion pick, Angelo? I chose 1997's L.A. Confidential, another one of my absolute favorites. Not just the writing, but the characters, the ensemble. Also stars Kevin Spacey. You've got the corrupt cops. You've got a hidden in plain sight criminal. Also with the pseudonym in a way with how it. Was kind of given. I don't want to give anything away for people.
57:33 I mean, I know it's been almost 30 years since this movie's been out, so you should have watched it by now. Um, but there's a particular name that was given to like an unknown boogeyman and somehow gets attached to this particular, um, person behind. All the cry, uh, Ro, Ro, Rossi, Rossi, Tomasi, Tomasi. Yes. Um, But it's one of my faves. And plus, I mean, you've got theâ I love that movie too. Yeah, theâ oh, my God. Sorry, I'm having a hard time finding my words. Well, you've got to think. Kevin Spacey had likeâ 40s. 50s, yeah.
58:14 Thatâ That just. Likeâ Oh, my God. You're going to have to edit my whole thing. Film noir. Yes. You know that it'sâ just, you know, that music, that setting, and you've got the, you know, the, the press where they were, you know, it's kind of like in the vein of, you know, Chicago where the press was so into the intrigue. It didn't matter the, you know, the, the crime or the murder or anything. It was just, you know, headlines and news and, and things like that. And you throw in, you. Know, the, the Hollywood or the Hollywood aspect with that. So, you know, you've got, you know, call girls and, you know, it's just, Like I said, the whole corrupt cop thing.
58:56 And it's just such a great movie. Yeah. I love it. And what's sad, though, is that it's so good that I don't know if we'll ever get a movie like that anymore. Something that kind of scale. Yeah. You know, that isn't a sequel to something or a giant blockbuster, but yeah. And you gotta think like Kevin Spacey went from the, the screenplays that he went through in the, like a short amount of time, seven usual suspects, LA confidential. I mean, say what you want about the man but he knew what good riding was. Yeah stream of bangers for sure and so i mean just diverse even with i mean just everything that he is uh you know been in um yeah yeah it just he could be just that absolute creep and then he could you know play it play a decent uh you know character and and things like that but yeah those those three yeah yeah like you said back that's a good triple feature right there yeah oh absolutely um the whole, Oh my God, what's in the box kind of so say, and then, you know, his trying to have a bit of a redemption arc, you know, and this, um, but he still winds up having a helpful hand, uh, in getting to the person responsible for, for all the things.
1:00:19 So he's, you know, he, um, was very useful in that still. Yeah. Great movies. Definitely. Yeah. Checked. I mean, God, yeah. Yeah. That also won, um, If I remember right, Best Original Screenplay, as well as it got Kim Basinger, Best Supporting Actress, Oscar for that, too. Well, that is going to be a fade-out on The Usual Suspects, a script by Christopher McQuarrie. I want to thank my guest for a second time, Angela Norris. Angela, what's coming up next for you? I was telling you earlier, I know you're on an episode of a film by Clerks 2, but I don't know if there's anything else you want to jump out there. Yeah, we just had a fun month.
1:01:00 We've done Super Troopers. We've done Clerks 2. Jeff and I just. Did My Super Ex-Girlfriend, which, to be honest, it's an atrocious movie, but it's a fun podcast, and I basically roast it. I've got a bunch of stuff coming up as far as like The Mummy Returns, Harry Potter. And of course, as we get into the fall and spooky stuff, I'm not a horror fan, but they're going to have me. Do some horror movies. So I can give my scaredy cat, you know, two cents in that. So it's going to be a fun year. All right. Yeah. Well, next time on A Script By, we are hitting the open road with Thelma and Louise, a script by Callie Corey, one of the most powerful road movies and a perfect blueprint on how to write a screenplay. If you want to know how to write a perfect act one, make sure you're here for this screenplay because it is a perfect act one. So be sure to keep up with A Film By with new episodes every Monday in our continuing Star Trek series, Phaser Set to Stun, every Wednesday.
1:02:08 You can also find us on YouTube, Instagram, Facebook, and X. Be sure to visit our official website at afilmbypodcast.com or email us at afilmbypodcast at gmail.com. We always love hearing from you, whether you're sharing your opinions, suggesting future episodes, or just debating great movies. Until next time, I am Brad Kozo, and remember, every great film begins with a great script.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Goodpods
Pandora
Amazon Music
iHeartRadio
Castbox
Deezer
TuneIn
Podcast Addict
Podchaser
Spreaker
JioSaavn
Castro
RSS Feed