Ready for exclusive content? Our Patreon now offers a free 7-day trial! Hit the Exclusive Content button below now!
May 25, 2026

Bryan Singer - Superman Returns

Bryan Singer - Superman Returns
Bryan Singer - Superman Returns
A Film By...
Bryan Singer - Superman Returns

Depp & Marsden Month continues! Jeff welcomes John Reid of the https://www.30podcast.com/ to the show for a discussion about their shared love for Superman in this super-sized episode that looks at Bryan Singer's 2006 effort that brought their...

Depp & Marsden Month continues!


Jeff welcomes John Reid of the 30something Movie Podcast to the show for a discussion about their shared love for Superman in this super-sized episode that looks at Bryan Singer's 2006 effort that brought their favorite superhero back to movie theaters, Superman Returns!

This episode is available AD-FREE with an additional 30 minutes on our Patreon right now! Check out what they've got for "Superman Show and Tell," and find out what Superman essentials you need during "John Reid Recommends." Get the extended version without all the commercials when you get started with a FREE 7-day trial. We've got plenty of exclusive content and episodes that you'll only find there! You can also sign up as a free member!

Check out our NEW YouTube Channel and subscribe now! Our new series Previously On... is exclusively available over on YouTube to cover your favorite TV shows, and ours!

Connect with us on social media and our website!

0:00 It's a bird, it's a plane. It's a film by Brian Singer, his two thousand and six effort to bring the Man of Steel back to the big screen. Superman Returns. Bobby used to say that you were put here for reasons, so you. Pull in last week because he's still stands for truth, justice, all that stuff. No, look, it's you wanted to see me.

0:41 Hello everybody, I'm Jeff Johnson and this is a Film by podcast and we have been discussing and celebrating the films of two thousand and one and two thousand and six, the twentieth fifth anniversaries, the twentieth anniversaries. As it were. I knew we decided to do this. There was no way I was going to skip out on today's film. Uh, Superman Returns. Those of you, if you've followed the show at all over the years, you know I am a huge Superman fan and I could not think of anyone better to have a conversation with today than someone who I have to believe shares my fandom.

1:25 Definitely, I would. I would say has an expert level knowledge on the Man of Steel. I'm talking about none other than John Reid of the thirty something Movie Podcast. It has been a while, my friend, haven't seen you for a few. Years, but I was here. I hear you every week. Yeah, and uh, it's great to see you again. How you how you been. Yeah, it's a I think I think since our our time at Shirleyfest a little while back, that was that was the last time we saw each other. But yeah, it's it's been a roller coaster of a couple of years. We'll put it that way. It's okay. Yeah, well, John, all great superheroes have an interesting origin story.

2:05 And I know we share a lot of listeners, but for some of the film by listeners that maybe don't know about the thirty something movie podcast, can you give us that show's origin? Yeah, absolutely so, thirty seventing podcasts. We most of us are a bunch of teachers. In fact, we worked in the same building together and we would sit around during our lunch period and we would talk movies. We all had the same lunch. We'd sit around, we talk and I had gotten into listening to podcasts, and this is like the first go around for podcasts when they first when they were still pretty niche and I had been listening to some and I was like, you know what, I really want to try this out. I had gone to school originally for journalism instead of education, and I always loved the idea. I was like, well, I love newspaper journalism, but maybe I want to dabble a little bit in radio. That might be kind of fun. And then eventually I switched over to education and that kind of got set off to the side. And then when I found out, well, you can do this thing relatively for free, and you can do whatever show you want, and it's called a podcast. So my buddies and I was sitting around talking about movies. We were arguing one day, kind of arguing, we kind of came to the conclusion We're like, is nineteen eighty four the greatest year for movies?

3:15 And we had we were having a little bit of a debate. And after that lunch period, I came back to the other guys and I said, Hey, guys, I've been wanting to do a podcast, and do you guys want to do it with me? Like, do you want? Like, we'll get together, we'll just talk movies. And their response to me was, I'll paraphrase to keep it a little family friendly. But their response to me was like in Jay and Silent, Bob stripe back his response to the heck is a podcast, And so we all got together. So we started in twenty fifteen. So we've been going this our eleventh year now, and our idea was, well, how do we keep this going and not run out of ideas? And we said, well, at the moment, we're looking back on movies that are about thirty years old.

3:58 So we figured, well, then let's do that. Let's every year, let's look at movies that are hitting their thirtieth anniversary. So we started with eighty four eighty five and from there we've progressed onwards. So we're currently in nineteen ninety six right now. Ninety six, yeah, we I remember a couple of seasons ago we did a limited series called nineteen ninety six. Yeah a lot. I thought, we're a couple of years ahead of the thirty something movie podcast. So let's just get in and have a couple of these and get and then get out of their way, because I know they're they're gonna. Have some awesome stuff for us here in a few years. But you're not. That's not the only one though. I mean again, John, you are a huge fan of Superman. Yes, you got another project. You got like a like a side project as it were.

4:43 Can we talk about that one? Yeah? Yeah, uh, don't tell my main squeeze this is my this is my side check podcast. Yeah. The other one, this is the podcast full of Kryptonite. And I had started that one. Dean Jason from the Sureley You Can Be Serious podcast. We all simultaneously we're talking to each other, realized we all loved the TV show Superman and Lois when it was getting started. We were excited by the idea of it coming out. And so before that show even came out, we had been looking at trailers, we had been looking at news that was coming out, and the three of us kind of got together and said, you want to do a podcast about this? I mean, we have one night a week maybe that we can do this. And so for the first I would say, at least the first couple of seasons, it was heavily. It was myself, d it was Jason, and then for the last couple of seasons, Dan Jason fell off a little. They were, I mean, obviously their podcast is ramping up, and so they were getting busier with that, and so the last let's say season and a half, it was me and occasionally one of them, or we might have another guest pop in to help guest host with that. But that one was tracking the TV show Superman and Lois, and we did a few other special episodes here and there where we just did kind of general Superman stuff too, or new projects that were coming out. And when that show came to an end, I was like, well, I want to keep this going because I love Superman and I would love to keep talking about Superman. So, like an idiot, I made a spreadsheet that had every other Superman TV show that had ever been created, and I said, you know, here's what I'm doing. I'm just gonna go through all of them. I'm gonna start with Smallville and

6:15 I'm going to run through all ten seasons of Smallville. Then maybe I'll go back and do the Adventures of Superman with George Reeve, and then I'll do I don't know, maybe one of the cartoons, and then I'll do Lois and Clark something like that. I mean, I've got pretty much everything on physical media back here, so I'm like, I have them, so let's just run through and do them and I got through a few episodes of Smallville and life found a way and ended up there was ended up losing my job that I had had for a few years, and so that that put a little bit of a that put a little kryptonite in my crawl. And so from that point, I like Superman. I disappeared slightly for about a year or so from that one, but I have got plans for that one to come on back. So I may have a potential co host to come on with me for that one, and we may be we may be throwing the podcast full of kryptonite into the sun and letting it recharge, and hopefully we're going to come back and and dive into Smallville the first season of Smallville, hopefully this summer. That's fingers crossed.

7:16 That's the plan. We we fans can rejoice and because if you're gonna just keep this thing going, there is no shortage of Superman media on television. And I know, I know we're gonna talk like when we do a little we're gonna have. A little Patreon bonus for our listeners, those that follow us on Patreon, and I know, I know you've got some recommendations for us later later in this hour. Yeah, absolutely, so John, real quick. I know we got to talk about Superman returns. I know we got to talk about Brian Singer. But but real quick, just your fandom with the Man of Steel, Like, can you tell me how how does it begin? You know, do you remember you remember how old you were? Do you remember what it was that that you saw or that you read.

7:59 Or I don't remember exactly how old I was, because it was as far back as I can imagine, it was always there. My dad loved the Superman movies. I was born in eighty and so my dad loved the Christopher Reeve movies. We would constantly and he loved Superman too. Like he around our house the phrase, you know, kneel before ZOD or wrong again Zod or something. Whenever I, as a little kid, would do something and I would like try to challenge my dad on something, whether it was joking or not, he'd be like, wrong again, ZOD. So, I mean that was the kind of stuff that was just the oxygen of our house growing up. And so as far back as I can remember, you know, there was the you know, there was like the Ruby Spears cartoons, there was the Super friends. There was the Action figures, there was the Christopher Reeve movies. I think what really kind of you know, kickstarted it from a yeah, I like Superman into a I am now kind of obsessed with this and I want to consume everything that is possibly available on this topic. Was we were living we'd moved over to England and we were living in the UK and the American comics, you know, you can get him over there, but they're a little harder to come by.

9:09 And so my dad went on a business trip back to the States and he brought back a couple of comics for me. He brought back Batman number four ninety nine, which is not too long after Batman's back had been broken in the Nightfall storyline and the new Azrael Batman had taken over as the new bat That's where Bain first showed up in the Batman comics. And the other comic he brought me was Superman number eighty one, and this was not too long. This is part of the return of Superman after he had been killed a few years before, and the episod the issue of this one is Superman is in this black and silver suit flying towards you on the cover of this comic, and I remember my dad bringing these to me and handing me one, and Batman has these weird metallic claws, and he hands me the Superman one, and Superman's in this black and silver suit, and I'm going, the heck happened Superman? What is going on here? And so I started reading it and then I just completely got consumed by the Then I went back and got the graphic novel for the Death of Superman, and kind of from that point on, We're off to the races. It was. From that point on it was okay, well, now I need to get every Superman comic that comes after this, and I mean, that's that's the nineties, so you're talking kind of almost prime time, you know, the peak of some of the Superman storytelling at that point. And so at that point I was just kind of whatever Superman, you know, to to paraphraser to quote one of my co hosts, Pat Cannagallo, more Superman, more better. So whatever came out, I needed

10:39 to consume it. Well, let's consume a little bit of knowledge about Brian Singer John three things you may not know about him? And I got a quote about Superman from Brian Singer, so amazingly enough, he initially turns down the job to direct X Me not once, but three times, believing that comic books were unintelligent, never read a comic book. And then someone has the good sense to put a couple books in his hand. He reads them, he watches the X Men animated series, and then he has a complete change of heart and decides, Yep, this is good stuff.

11:20 I'm gonna do it. He's a huge fan of Star Trek, primarily the original series from nineteen sixty six. Keep in mind listeners that are ongoing Star Trek theme series Phasers Set to Stun is currently celebrating the sixtieth anniversary of the original show right now. We got a new episode dropping this Wednesday, so it's there for you. And Singer a big fan that he is. He has a cameo in Star Trek Nemesis, playing one of the crewmen on the bridge of the Enterprise because it all comes back to Trek. So his childhood friend growing up none other than Ethan Hawke, and Singer has a couple famous cousins in the business. Uh, John, you're not in your head, and he guesses as to who these two famous cousins. Are you want to take a take a crack at it?

12:12 The famous cousins, I don't know. I've heard that, but I don't know who they are. Well, it's all in the name, uh beast Masters. Mark Singer is one cousin. And uh that that hell Raiser from Beaumont, Uh Indiana. Uh Lori Singer from Footloose. Uh that's that's his other cousin. So oh that's awesome. No, I didn't know them. No. So when you ask him about the Superman character, Bryan Singer had this to say, quote, I identify with Superman. I am adopted, I am an only child, and I love the idea that he comes from another world, that he's the ultimate immigrant, he has all these extraordinary powers, and he has a righteousness about him.

12:56 I dig that. Yeah. Yeah, I think we all. I think we all identify with Superman, or at least you want to identify with Superman. So there's so much about the character before we even dive into the movie itself. Just the kind of character in general. There's so much about this character. And that's why I I know a lot of people kind of divide themselves up between Well, I'm a Superman person or I'm a Batman person, and I enjoy both, but I think when it comes down to it, I absolutely lean more towards the Superman type of mentality. Batman's cool, but there's something about and maybe it's maybe it takes a special kind of nerd, but I think I'm much more of a Superman fan. I see much more of the optimism in Superman. Like Batman is always looking at everybody's angles, Superman is always looking at everybody's goodness, and Batman, I mean, Superman is I'm also a big fan of mister Rogers, Fred Rogers. I think if you're a Fred Rogers fan, you're also probably a Superman fan, because there's that same kind of optimism. There's that you know, you almost feel like like Superman when he rescues somebody or he helps somebody out. He's he almost feel like he could look at you and go, you know, I'm proud of you just the way you are. He's kind of like a superhero, Fred Rogers, We'll put it that way.

14:06 I love that John Good good call. So I'm gonna I'm gonna challenge you. You know, we have gone away this season from the deep synopsis on what the film's all about. And I think, listen, I'm having a way better time this season because we. Are summing them up in exactly five words. So the game, John, all right, I'm gonna ask you what is Superman Returns all about? And you have to tell me using exactly five words. Now, if there are four words, if there are six words, if it is not exactly five words, then we might as well just throw a chain full of cryptonide around your neck and drop in the sewer.

14:48 Because okay, and rightfully, so, yeah, okay, what do you got for us? John? H five words? And having been an English teacher, I'm going to assume that punctuation does not count as a word. It does not cont a word. Okay, all right, So the five words I'm gonna give you, I needed least two, maybe three question marks at the end of this. All right, what do you got? Okay, here's my five words synopsis spent the night with Superman. I'm giving it to you. Okay, I'm giving it to you. I'm giving it to you. Well, I will dive more into why I picked that in a little bit. Okay, all right, Well, because you have a follow up, because you can, you can, you can explain yourself, then I'm gonna allow that one. Okay, But so So Singer is filming X two x Men United, has this idea to bring Superman back to the big screen because he's been missing since the Quest for Peace. And John, let's you know you mentioned our good friends Jason and d shout out to the show You Can't Be Serious podcast, because I don't think you and I are in the same universe without those guys. They they you know, we find a common bond between those these guys. And you have been on their show talking Superman. Yeah, I have been on their show talking Superman. So and just recently, you know, last season we did one of our their famous what the heck Happened episodes and they we talked Superman return. So I'm gonna I'm gonna withstand. I'm gonna withhold certain things because I said I said my piece on their episode.

16:17 So listeners, if you haven't already. Go back to the show you hit Me Serious podcast. Uh, check out check out check out all their episodes. But just know anything that's got Superman, if you're not hearing me, you're definitely hearing John Reid. With these guys and uh, it's an awesome show. But uh, absolutely, And before you move on too much, so I do want to say, yeah, when when you did the episode with them where you interviewed them about their podcast, I love that. That was probably one of my favorite that was so well done by all of you guys. Well think I appreciate that. I uh, I just you know, because yeah, we're friends, but I'm also a fan. I love their show, and I just thought, man, it'd be cool to to ask some questions from a fans point of view, you know, a listener's point of view, because I bet, I bet, I'm not alone.

17:06 And you know, it was. It was a great time. I was. I was. I was very happy that they opened themselves up to that kind of questioning and we're very candid and we had a great time. And I do owe them. They said they're coming for me. They're like, well, we're gonna interview you. I was like, Okay, well I'm not the film by podcast is not as big as surely, but I'll accept that invitation. But Singer extends the invitation to his X Men and X two producer Lauren Shuler Donner about this idea. What if Superman was just missing for five years and then he came back, and he also shares it with her husband, Richard Donner, and the two of them just give him nothing but positive feedback. This is the way to go, I do you Let's just let's just have that conversation right now. I mean, he's retroact, like he's redcounting the whole series, like he's ignoring Superman three, Superman four.

18:00 How do you feel about that? John? You know I miss Gus Gorman. Yeah, part of the part of me thinks it's okay. I mean, growing up as a kid, I loved I know how messy three and four are, and I loved Superman three, and I watched Superman four, and so do I miss those now that they're considered gone. Yeah, a little bit. But you know, knowing especially for especially Quest for a Peace, I think, knowing how Christopher Reeve even felt about that movie, I'm kind of fine letting that one go. Even though I like to be a completist and have all my copies of the movies and enjoy all the movies, I'm okay letting that one go. Three is its own special little mess in the middle of it all. Richard Pryor is hilarious.

18:47 I love him in that movie. And there's so many we don't get the Clark and Superman Junkyard fight without Superman three, so I know. So the fact that that is now not existent in this universe, I'm a little sad for that, but I am I'm okay. I'm okay with them using this. There's there's a few little things I'm not okay with, but I'm okay with them kind of using this as a Let's just start from the two strongest entries, you know, the ones that Donner filmed back to back. Uh, let's start from there, and let's let's take the story on from that. I'm fine with. That, all right, Well, we're going to take the story on after we take a quick break.

19:28 When we return, John Reid and I will talk about the cast. Welcome back. I've got John Reid from the thirty something Movie podcast with me. We were talking about two thousand and six Superman returns, and I want to talk about Brandon Ralph playing Clark Kent and Superman. John, as you already know, Jim cavisl was lobbying hard intensil Town, Yeah to get this role and singer. You know, it's after the Passion of the Christ. Singers like he's just too famous. I can't we can't do it. And singer is insistent on an unknown actor.

20:12 Yeah, I mean yeah, Jim Cavizel I know, I know how much Donner likes to do the Christ's imagery with Superman, So I know Jim cavizl was was banking on that. He's like, well, what more could they want? It's super Jesus, Like, of course, of course they're going to take me. Yeah. So among you know, like singers like, no, it's got to be an unknown. We're going unknown. That's the only way we're. Going to do it. Among those at the time unknown actors that audition and and and lose out. Jhon Ham, who I always thought, man, give me like a Kingdom, come Superman. That's exactly John even now, I would take him even now, Oh.

20:54 Heck yeah, even now. Chris Pratt, who would. Find uh that one I didn't know find his place as star Lord. Yeah, he's up for it. This one surprised the heck out of me. Glenn Howardton auditioned, Wow, No, I didn't know that. Dennis Reynolds from it's always sunny in Philadelphia. Yeah, and then uh, just a little too soon because he ultimately does take the role. Henry Cavill, Yeah, is in there. I always thought. One one of my favorite movies is The Count of Monte Cristo from two thousand and two. Oh yeah, and Henry Cavell is a young you know, he's a young kid in that one. He's probably playing about a I don't know, maybe about a fifteen sixteen year old in that one. But I remember watching that movie and going, and this is four years before Superman returns.

21:41 I'm watching that movie. I'm going, that kid's face, that kid's face just looks like a Superman like that, Hire him right away. The first time I remember seeing Cavell was in a film he did called Immortals. Yes, and even then, like he I mean, he had he was chiseled, he didn't have necessarily the bull, but you're right, that face is like, man, they should get this guy to play Superman at some point. Because he was in he was in that Count of Money Cristo, and then he was in The Tutors too. I think, yeah, yeah, tutors Y, Yeah, John, Is there an alternate universe where singer likes Henry Cavill, casts him, and then we maybe get, like all three or four movies, there's no Snyder verse and we just have a Henry Cavill superman.

22:26 I think there's a possibility. I I'm going to lean towards maybe the alternate universe wouldn't be too different, because I don't know, at least for me, and at least I don't know the circles that that I tend to talk in. I don't know that Brandon Routh is the reason why people have issues with the movie. I think he's Yeah. I mean, I think he's a great successor to Christopher Reeve. I mean he he pulls this Everything they've asked him to do, he pulls off masterfully in this movie. I think. I think the weaknesses are in other parts of the movie. So I don't know if even having a Henry Cavill or somebody like that. I don't know that this movie gets its sequels because I don't think it's the actor that's I don't think the answer it's the actor that's bringing it down.

23:09 Well, it's definitely not Ralph that's bringing it down. Interestingly enough, he auditions and gets turned down, but it's not for this movie. It's it's for Smallville. He's up for Clark Kenton Smallville. He gets turned down, and then it's Brian Singer who finds him working at Lucky Strike Bowling in Hollywood and sees the the Christopher Reeve resemblance. The role is pretty much his after Reeve's widow Dana also comments about the striking resemblance. And I mean the guy just looks he's.

23:50 Christopher Reeve, you know. I mean he embodies the Clark Kent performance in this movie like like no other I could. I think packs on twenty pounds of muscle to fill the suit out. I think he looks fantastic. Your thoughts, John on how he looks in the suit and the suit in general, because every time we get a new movie, we're we're gonna tweak the suit a little bit. What did you think of this suit? Are you a fan? I love this suit, and I know people had issues with the coloring of the suit. I didn't have issues with the color and the suit. I think at this point, you're in a different era of comic book movies. You've still got X Men that don't have the X Men comic book uniforms and so doing a little bit of a different coloring on it. The whole color palette of this movie is different than the Donner movies anyway. So I mean, I think it just it fits the bright Christopher Reeves Superman suit does not fit in this universe, and so I think the updating of this I think they did a great job with it. I think he looks amazing in it, you know, like you said, he's very much He could practically be a clone of Christopher Reeve.

24:55 They actually end up reusing this suit in the series Analey of Smallville as well. They never actually Tom Welling never actually wanted to fully put the suit on, so you don't actually see Tom Welling fully wearing it. But it was fun to see that kind of make a reappearance later on at the end of Smallville. I'm like, that's the return suit. That's awesome, that's amazing. I love it. John controversial topic amongst Superman fans. I don't know if you want to take a. Stand or you know, not to put you on the spot, but Superman on TV, on film trunks or no trunks.

25:38 You know, I've I've gone back and forth on this and I've I've been okay with both, depending on the design, I've been okay with both. I think where I land now at this point in my life is it's Superman with the trunks, because I think part of the reason. I don't remember where I read this, but it's again not to compare Superman Batman, but the idea. The idea of Batman is he is there to scare people. He's there to strike fear in the hearts of criminals because they are a fearful and cowardly lot. But Superman is there to put people at ease. And I forget where I read this, but somebody said that Superman's reason for wearing these trunks is he's kind of making him look like he's making himself look like one of the old circus strong men. And the idea of the trunks is I'm gonna put you at ease because maybe I do look a little ridiculous, but that's kind of part of it.

26:30 It's so that you're not afraid of me. I am. I have these godlike powers, but I'm going to do some stuff so that when you look at me, you're not necessarily thinking godlike. You might be thinking why are his under ruths on the outside. But I'm gonna put you at ease by you know, maybe maybe throwing you off just a little bit. But I'm not this dark, scary, brooding, fearful character. I am myself. I am pro trunks only because when we see the heroes without the trunks, it's kind of ret conning our childhood. John you mentioned under rus and you know I wore the Superman under rus and proudly, and uh, you know I don't I don't want that ret con dowt a out of the out of the timeline.

27:12 So yes, absolutely. Kate Bosworth playing Lois Lane, she uh she beats out a then unknown Amy Adams. Again. You know we we we had these people lined up. Uh Initially, Singer convinces Kevin space He's convinced by Kevin Spacey. Kate Bosworth is the way to go. They did that movie, the. Bobby Fisher movie, not Bobby Fisher, is it Bobby Bobby Bobby Darren Bobby Fisher is the chess player. Yeah, the under the Sea. I think something like that. Yea, Spacey I think Spacey is like the he's he's the star, He's got the star power at this point, and he he kind of convinces Space or singer and singers like, Okay, I've I've I've made my my thoughts clear, my my viewpoint on Kate and on the show that you can't be serious episode for Superman returns, What's What's What's your take on her performance as Lois Lane.

28:08 She's probably one of my least favorite Lois Lanes. She's a little too subdued for me. She's not the she has moments where she's the I want. I want my Lois Lane to be a tough as nails firecracker. Just she can hold her own with whoever she's in the room with. Frankly, she she holds her own with Superman. So if you're going to stand up to this godlike figure, I picture a Lois Lane as somebody who could walk in and interview Batman and not be intimidated. In fact, there is to pull in a comic book story. There was a comic book story a few years ago where Batman comes to it. It's Superman Lois and they have their son, Jonathan Kent at that point in the comics, and there's a point where I think somebody knocks at the door, and Jonathan Kent goes to answer it and it's Batman and he makes a comment. Then he goes, wait a minute. Batman knocks at the door, and Batman very quietly says, or Lois I think quietly says something like yep, he tried not knocking once and he knows better now. Oh okay, And so I'm like, okay, that is the lowest Lane I want. I want to Lois Lane, who can stand in a room with the rest of the Justice League, could stand up to any of these other people and not be intimidated at all. There are little, teeny tiny slight moments of this. When she's on the yacht with Lex Luthor. You know, she's holding Jason, She's on the yacht. He's right up in her face. He's screaming at her. She's like, she's got these little snide comments for him, a little back and forth that I like.

29:37 But I needed that to be her in the entire movie. And there were just so many times in this movie where her is Lowis Lane. I'm not getting it because that's not Lois Lane. To me, is where she is because she has no fear and she will do whatever it takes. She can't spell worth anything, but she has no fear and she will do whatever it takes to get the story. I just I don't get that from Kate Bosworth. Now, I mean I get it in the writing. You know you mentioned here a terrible spelling. I love that Singer does such an incredible job with this script where he ties it directly to Superman one and Superman two, with some of those things, you know, her asking like.

30:18 How do you spoke catastrophe? How many absent? None? Yeah? Yeah, I do like that. But I'm with you. I just she's not the right choice, you know. And I'm not saying she's not a talented actrual she is. I just don't think she's right for les Lane. Yeah. I do think Kevin Spacey was right for Lex Luthor. What do you think I do? My thoughts on this one. I wish here's where we might go into more detail on this a little bit later, But I kind of wish, for Kevin Spacey's sake that there had been a little bit less homaging to the Donner verse. I would love Kevin Spacey to have been able to put more of his own personal twist on Lex Luthor. He the thing that bothered me, and even as a huge Superman fan, huge you know Donner movie Superman fan, the first time I saw this in theaters, I'm sitting there, I'm watching it in theaters. When they started to directly quote he said word for word exactly the same stuff that Gene Hackman had said. The first time it happened, I'm like, Oh, look at that. They're a little they're throwing a little Easter egg for us. And then I think the second time it happened, I was like, oh, look at that, they're still doing it. And so I just I wish and knowing Kevin Spacey before seeing him in this, I hadn't necessarily seen him in much, but I had seen him in seven, and I'm going, Okay, well, if we're going to take the guy from seven and we're going to make him Lex Luthor, then I don't I don't want him to be this just absolutely creepy, psychotic guy.

31:48 But I want to see a little bit more. I want to see a little less Gene Hackman in his performance, and I want to see a little bit more Lex Luthor. And that same scene I just mentioned about, you know, Lois and her kind of trading barbs with Lex Luthor. One thing he does do better than Gene Hackman is he is a he's a scary Lex Luthor. U. Yes, Gene Hackman. To me, I'm never necessarily afraid of him in that kind of you know, he's he's unpredictable and he's scary kind of a way. It's I'm afraid of his intelligence. With Gene Hackman, you know, what is he possibly capable of? And and he doesn't have the same moral compass as anybody else. Kevin Spacey lends a little bit extra scariness to his Lex Luthor, and I wish he had been given a little bit of a longer leash to do more of that.

32:34 I think it's I think it's charisma versus intensity when you're looking at the two of them, Yes Hackman, Yeah, you're right. You can't really be afraid of Hackman because he's so charismatics as Luther. You know. And it's and it's those little comedic moments he has, you know, miss Tesmacher, Lex, my mother lives in Hackensacks and he looks at the watch. No, not anymore. It's you. You have you kind of chuckle, you know, you're like, Oh, he's so cool even when he's a bad guy. Otis Burg, Otis Otisburg. It's a little place, John. But I feel like if you if you have Spacey doing that, you know, and Mistex Smoker says, my mother lives in Hackensack.

33:21 He's not looking at his watch. He's like looking at her, like with a face, you know, like like that John Doe face maybe from seven and you're like, oh. This guy's he's a psychopath. Yeah, at the end, at the end when when she kicks the crystals out of the helicopter as they're trying to escape from the island, and he's like, what did you do to me this, Lex Luthor? And I don't know, maybe you don't do it in a movie that's PG thirteen and kids are going to come see. But if it's Kevin Spacey Lex Luthor, I'm feeling like he kicks her out the helicopter door while it's mid flight. Yeah, like I see him going go get him and like shoving her around, you know, something something to that effect. I'm a fan. I'm a fan of space He's Lex Luthor though, absolutely, I think you know, and I know we could talk for hours about Lex Luthor's.

34:09 But we're not gonna do that. But uh he he would. Definitely be up there among the among the greats as far as I'm concerned. We we started this month off, we're talking about Johnny Depp and James Marsden, and I gotta be honest with you. Initially, I wasn't thinking that we're gonna talk Superman. I knew were gonna talk Superman returns, but I had it. I had it a couple months away from now, and then I was like, what am I doing. It's James Marsden, like, you gotta talk Superman and you gotta. Talk X Men. This this guy is in two of the biggest superhero franchises in the same summer. James Marsen here playing Richard White, a new new character. I don't know if he's I don't know what is there is there a comic uh accuracy here?

34:52 Is there was there ever a Richard White, because I don't remember that when I read the comics. I feel like Perry White had Perry White had a son in the comics. This was kind of like in the eighties, maybe early nineties, and at one point then I believe his son died and I'm trying to remember if it was because of Lex Luthor. I'm a little I'm a little fuzzier on that history, but at one point Perry White did have a child. Yeah, I'm a little fuzzy on the details of that one, though. I like what Marson's doing here because you you got this guy, Richard White. He's heir to the Bugle Empire, as as it were. He's the assistant editor, right, he's Perry's what, he's Perry's son, Parry's nephew something like that.

35:43 He's he's with Lois Lane, He's that. You got to make him a cool, charismatic guy. Right. He's got a plane, he's a pilot. He's dashingly handsome, you know. He's he's a great dad to to her son. He's a great husband, you know, he's a great whatever. I don't know. It's nice seeing James Marsen playing a heroic figure who's not a hero, if that makes sense. Yeah. I do feel bad for James Marsden because I think he gets jokingly, he gets type cast as the guy that the girl doesn't quite want. Yeah, so because in this one, he's you know, he's I don't want to call him the backup plan. But here's kind of the backup plan. He's when your austions are Superman. I think he's the backup plan. In the Notebook, he kind of becomes the backup plan to Ryan Gosling. In the X Men movies, he becomes the backup plan to Wolverine.

36:39 So I always felt a little bad for James Mars and I'm like, he seems like such a nice guy. It's he's I mean, you gotta you gotta give him cdit because in some of these he does have the girl, Like he's with Lewis Lane, he's with Jane Gray. But he's not the first choice, right, you know, he's just he's he's like, I'm gonna settle for him. I can't, you know, I want to be with this guy, but I'll bring this guy home to mom. In all and in all those situations, he never does anything to make you look at him and go oh, That's definitely why she should be with Superman. Definitely why she should be with Logan. Every single time he's he's a nice guy, like he doesn't he doesn't have any major red flag flaws in any of these situations. So he's That's one thing I do appreciate. I appreciate about this is I feel like that's a bit of a step up in storytelling where it's like he's a viable option for someone to, you know, be your partner in life.

37:31 He's not, you know, there's not gonna be some horrible secret you find out about him later on. He's who he is. He's a nice guy. Yeah, and well, you know, like Lois, I know where I know we'll get to it here when we talk about the scenes, but there's a moment where she almost kisses Superman. Yeah, stops herself. It's like, Richard's a good guy. He's and he never left. He didn't leave me, you know. And I really appreciate that. We don't see Superman have to save Richard. It's Richard is saving Lois and Jason, and Superman's kind of giving him the assist. That's I thought that was brilliant. How he was like, hey, do you got the Superman's like hey, you Like when he's getting him out of the boat, he knows, hey do you got him? He's like I got him.

38:11 He's like all right, hold on, and it's like, let the guy rescue his family. Superman's not there. To take the credit, So I really like how his character's written. I really like what James Marson's doing in this John, anyone you want to talk about before we we move on. I know, I know, I just I'm not all due respect to Franklin Jella, skeletor himself, you know, playing Perry White. I guess we should talk while we're talking about him, So let's talk about him. Yeah, he's a he's a fun Perry White. I like him as Perry White. He's kind of he's got that kind of like you know, grizzled newspaperman vibe to him, like he's he's definitely seen some crap and he's kind of got a little no nonsense stuff about him. And so I like him. I like him as a Perry White. He's, you know, compared with other iterations, he's he's the kind of guy I expect to be running a newspaper. So yeah, no, I love him, and I've loved him in so many other things, the seventies, Dracula, that like you mentioned skeletor that.

39:09 Yeah, yeah, he's I like what he's doing with Perry White here. Singer specifically cautions him too, to bring it down a couple notches. I don't want someone that's boisterous. I don't want someone that's flying off the handle. Specifically because they didn't want to see like a JK. Simmons, j Jonah Jamison, because you got you know, we got same army spider man happening, and they wanted to be careful not to. Have that same flavor as it were. But he's fun, he's I like, there's a snarkiness to how he treats Lewis, you know, and it's where he's where he was putting in place. I think it works, definitely like it.

39:52 Uh, let's talk a little bit about this background of this film. It's ah and again all due respect, I know there's a ton of people we could talking about. But we we only have so much time. So uh, you know, the film originally talking about people that we can't really talk about, but we'll talk about for a minute because you mentioned the character already, or at least your your father mentioned the character. Uh. This film originally was intended to include the return of General Zod. Singer was insistent that the only person that could play him was Jude law I wholeheartedly agree with that that choice. I think that would have been amazing. I know what Jude Law was. Jude Law was also involved as they were doing some different iterations during that whole development hell period where they were running all the different possibilities they had that I'm trying to remember which one Jude Law was going to be involved.

40:46 Was it? Oh, it might have been fly By? Yeah, because there was versus. There was a Batman versus Superman, okay, And I feel like at one point, you know, Matt Damon was possibly involved, Jude Law was possibly involved. Josh Hartnett's name kept getting thrown around, and I want to say it was either the Batman versus Superman that they were talking through like in two thousand and one, or it was the Superman Flyby. I think you're right. I think it was the Batman versus Superman. Okay, Uh, McK g. Had the I think it was Mick G that was gonna do fly By if I'm not mistaken. I think so it was that the JJ Abrams. I think that was the Abrams, yeah, Abrams script. And that might even been a Brennan Fraser. I know he was like Hartnon and Fraser were both you know in the running there, that's a that's a podcast onto itself, like just.

41:36 The just the the what ifs, you know, Nick Cage and you know everything, Tim Burton, Kevin Smith. There was so many possibilities. Uh, that's your that's your alternate video store right there. Yeah, there we go. We might we might cover that at some point. We did. We did Batman, We did Richard Donner's Batman, so why not do that? But yeah, Jude Law says absolutely not. He turns it down several times. Since Senor says, well, if I can't have Jude Law, then there's no ZOD. He writes them out of the script. And I agree with that. I think that was the right way. To do it. This movie. Leaps tall buildings in a single bound. At the thirty third Saturn Awards, John when and you know this because you know it all about Superman, But for our listeners it wins Best Actor for Brandon Routh, Best Score for John Ottman, Best Screenplay for Michael Doherty and Dan Harris, Best Fantasy Film, and Best Director for Brian Singer.

42:28 It's quite a haul. Yeah yeah. Filming for the Superman Return sequel was slated to begin in mid two thousand and seven. I still don't understand the politics that were involved with the execs and everything else going on. But after several production delays, the Warner Brothers studio president Alan Horn states that Superman Returns was very successful, but that it quote should have done five hundred million world why we should have had perhaps a little more action to satisfy the young male crowd. Now, singer, who has some clout at this point in his career and has grown impatient with the execs, has no loss for is no loss for words for him. He's quoted saying the movie made four hundred million. I don't know what constitutes underperforming these days.

43:24 Yeah, and ultimately he leaves to pursue other projects. John anything fun? I know, I know you've got a I know you've got a fortress of solitude's worth of knowledge about. The making of this movie. But can you can you give us a couple couple. Fun facts about the you know, I'm kind of I'm kind of hitting bullet points. I'm, you know, faster than this beating bullet point. But what do you got anything you want to share with us? So one of the things I read that I thought was really unfair to the people making these movies. Was and I don't know how accurate this is, but I've read it in a couple of different places. Now, when they were looking at the the budget of this movie versus the box office, they actually were counting in the budget some of the money that has been spent during that production hell period. So not not even what this movie was involved in. Not fair at all. And so that, I mean, that's part of what makes me even more angry, because I remember when this one came out, and I remember talking with some friends and we were just trying to imagine in our heads. We're like, okay, so not that you can have too many complaints about the Christopher Reeve movies, but you know some of the complaints where now we're here, we're in the two thousands. We've got CGI when it's needed. You know, we can do all kinds of other practical effects that we maybe couldn't even do back in the seventies and eighties. I mean, let's let's crack it open. We've got so many good villains.

44:46 We could do Brainiac, we could do whatever, like so many good, good Superman villains. And there was the excitement of that so then when I you know, hear things like that where it's like, well, they counted all the years that Brian Singer was not even involved in this, they're counting the spending they did on those other projects towards the budget of his movie, and then they're telling him it didn't make enough money. That's the kind of stuff that frustrates me because it's it's the what could have been with this onete. Yeah, that's absolutely asinine to me. You can't say, hey, we you know all this money we sunk into development, you you know you got to pay that bill. Yeah, yeah, that's it's just wrong speaking of development.

45:27 And I want I wanted to see Ralph get a chance to break loose a little bit more. He was very I love his Superman in this movie, but he's also very subdued. And I also had read somewhere he only has eighty three lines of dialogue in this movie, so he doesn't talk much. There is a deleted scene though, where he finds that the Fortress of Solitude has been broken into and he enraged. He is just like he unleashes this anger, you know, screaming and flying into space. And I believe Ralph has been quoted as saying, like this was it felt deeply unsupermanly, but it also helped him like kind of connect with this character and maybe the tension that this character is dealing with and what he's going through emotionally. And I would have loved to see a less subdued, you know, break out of his shell a little bit more Brandon Ralph Superman in a sequel and just and that's one of the other things that aggravates me that we never got it.

46:25 He doesn't get his moment. Like Rea, like in Superman, Lois, Lois dies in the earthquake. Absolutely reeve gets that rage moment. Ye Cavel no choice but to end Zod's life. Has that rage moment, right Ralph Ralph, Ralph didn't get his. And I agree with you. We we missed out on a sequel. They were looking at Brainiac, they're looking at Bizarro. That would have been that would have been great. The whole idea was let's bring some Kryptonians back, but maybe let's not do what we've already done. Let's not bring Zod and Ursa non, Let's let's see some other guys in action.

47:10 We've MultiMate movies let's do somebody other than do somethe else. Yeah, speaking of all that research, all that developmental time, I do know that one more thing I'll give you before we take a quick break. DC opens the vault and says, here is everything that we've got on the last dating back to nineteen eighty six. Here's all the developmental information we've got for movies. Have at it. Brian Singer politely says, no, thank you, tells the studio no, no, no. I all I need is to follow the continuity set forth by Richard Donner.

47:51 That's it. Don't want anything else, don't eat So yeah, I dig it, like ultimately, like I said, the fact that. We rely so heavily on the. Donner storytelling, the John Williams score, the mannerism like Ralph's Clark Ken is perfect. He like the bumbling Clark that's wants to be cool, but just as forever a goof Like I think it's all there. I really enjoy it. I remember, John, do you remember the first time you saw that teaser and you heard the Marlon Brando Darrell dialogue, and you've got the John Williams score. I just maybe one of my all time favorite movie teasers, trailers.

48:38 Whatever you want to call it. I was just like, oh my god, they're Superman's coming back, but he's this is this is my Superman. It's yeah, yeah, do you remember do you remember seeing that trailer first time? Like you're just the feeling that. You had, absolutely like that. That is one of my memories up there with you know, waiting for somebody to download the Phantom Menace trailer for about forty five minutes before we could actually watch her. Was getting a chance and not having to wait forty five minutes this time around, but yeah, just getting a chance, Yes, getting a chance to see this movie trailer for a character, much like Star Wars episode one, we had waited. I mean you almost could have thought, well, maybe there's no more Superman ever, because you know Superman four, that's kind of where we left it, and we haven't had anything since then, so I'm not going to assume anything else is coming, just like with Star Wars, kind of assume everything's dead and gone and you just maybe read the books and have some fun with that. But yes, I remember this trailer as well as the Man of Steel trailer. I love that one as well. When that one first came out.

49:37 Just I was so excited, like I was, I was brand new. I was been brand new in my first job as a teacher. Like I remember this coming out. I remember running through the building finding the other people I knew that were nerds like me, and I was like, guys, we have got that. Whenever you've got a lunch break or a period off where you don't have kids, you got to come to my room because there's a trailer. We got to watch it. Oh nice. So last week we were talking about Pirates of the Caribbean, dead Man's Chest, David Angela and Hamber having a lot of fun set and sail with Jack Sparrow. Superman Returns nominated for the Academy Award for Best Visual Effects, but loses to Pirates of the Caribbean dead Man's Chest.

50:22 Did the Academy get that one right? Do you think? I mean, I know we had the Kraken and you know all that all that stuff and Pirates, but I don't know. I just I mean, it's Superman. Yeah. I feel like I feel like it maybe is an issue of quality over quantity or quantity over quality, because it definitely dead Man's Chest had more cgi than Superman did. I feel like Superman used it sparingly, which is always unless you absolutely need a CGI heavy movie. I'm always going to be somebody who wants to balance the practical with the CGI. I use it when it's needed, use it when it's when it's wise to use it. And so I started to get a little turned off by the Pirates of the Caribbean movies when they started to do more of that CGI. I'm like, does it look good? Yeah, it looks good, but I don't know.

51:12 I'm give me a give me a costume, and give me practical sets and give me things like that, and I'm happy. I mean, I'm a I'm a I'm a Ray Harry Housen fan. So I don't know stop motion. Give me some stop motion stuff. I love. I love Captain Jack. But the big action set piece in this movie, when Superman saves the plane, yes, I mean, it just blows my mind. I mean, I've seen the movie a hundred times probably, and I own it on Blu Ray. But every time that scene starts, I'm I'm ten years old again, and I'm just sitting there just in all and like, I believe in. Superman, you know, it's still.

51:52 Oh absolutely, I think it's still one of the most iconic in all the superhero movies we've had now, I think it's one of the most iconic scenes of any comic book movie, even of the ones we've had so many we've had an embarrassment of riches of comic book movies in the last several decades. That scene, if you asked me to list of like top five favorite moments in a comic book movie, it's definitely in that top five. It's got to be. And the fact, you know, we talked about how they kind of give us a little nostalgia. They throw like some throwback dialogue from the original movies. The fact that he uses the line you. Know yes staysally speaking, it's it's still the safe sway to fly. I hope this doesn't put any of you off flying. Yeah, yeah, well, and go back go back to the original not that Brian Singer wants to use source material, but go back to the original comics, and especially in the kind of in the eighties, you know, eighties and nineties iteration of Superman, the way he first meets Lois is he rescues a I think it's a space shuttle that she's on or a plane that she's on. That's how he meets her is he rescues her, he lands the shuttle or the plane, and then when she gets off, she immediately in some scenes she grabs his cake and she grabs his cape and goes, hey, wait, Buster, I got some questions for you.

53:03 Like number one, that's still my lowest lane, the one that will grab the godlike figures cape. Now, I know you're not supposed to tug on Superman's cape, but she does. She's the only one that's allowed to do it, as long as she doesn't spit into the wind. But yeah, I mean, that's that's kind of an iconic if if you've if you've immersed yourself in the comic books and you've got that history too, then him saving a plane not only just a plane, but a plane and a shuttle at the same time, him doing that is like, okay, well then this is you know, this is my my comic book stuff come to life. So that is I absolutely love that hole. That was the was that the that's the burn run? Yes, yeah, that's what that's Yeah, speaking of burn, not to kind of burn you want it wins it's nominated for the Commy Award, also nominated for a Golden Raspberry Award.

53:54 Yeah. Worst Supporting Actress for Cape Bosworth and she loses to Carmen Electric Uh for a double performance Date Movie and Scary Movie four. I would have to go back and see those two to know whether or not Kate should have got. It, because again. I have I have a I feel a certain way about Kate bos Bosworth's Leis Lane. And and that's all I'll say, uh, because we got to take another break, welcome back, all right. Uh, we got to talk about the scene. And John, I know you've got a scene in mind. I've got a scene in mind.

54:34 I'm gonna ask you, uh, specifically the scene you chose before you tell us what it is. What made you choose this scene? Was it the cinematography? Was it a strong performance? Is it the pivotal moment in Superman Returns? Is it? Is it something you you think? Maybe Amber Lewis was pissed off about. What do you what do you got for us? My answer is yes, it's okay. I think it's so many of those my scene. I think it's it's pivotal scene in the movie. It's the climax of Act one of the movie. It is technically and cinematographerly cinematography, that's not even a word. It's all of those. I love this scene. It's it's got, you know, some of the Superman lore in there. It's calling back to some stuff in the comics. Yeah, it is. It is an outstanding scene. I absolutely love it.

55:24 Okay, tell us the scene, all. Right, it is. It's the plane rescue. It's got to be the plane rescue. You kill me up. I'm like, well, there's only one. Yeah, is this this whole scene with the plane. It's as as kids who grew up watching the Christopher Reeve movies and then you know, getting to see someone because at this point we've also we've also seen some action in uh We've seen the animated series, We've seen Lois and Clark, We've seen Smallville, we've seen the Superboy TV show. We've seen a lot of different versions of Superman. But I don't think we've ever quite gotten the action we really really wanted from a big screen Superman like the stuff.

56:05 And I don't want to knock any of the stuff Christopher Reeve did because at the time they're doing what they've got the capability to do. But when you get to this, and this is what I wish the movie maybe had had a little bit more of. But when you get to this, you get to this plane rescue, this is I think everything we had wanted to see from a live action Superman. You want to see his strength, you want to see his he's got to think through this problem. You know, he's got to think at super speed, not just react at superspeed as he's saving this plane. And there is so much in this I think it's barely five minutes in this five minutes of the film. There is so much going on, and there's so many little things you can pick up on. As he's trying to rescue the plane. You're cutting back and forth. You get some little character moments with Lois and some of the other reporters that are on the plane. You get character moments with him as he's trying to, you know, save the plane. He's he's got One of the moments I love is he's trying to grab the wing of the plane. And I think too, this is one of the first times you actually get some of the physics of Superman, like you can't just grab a plane and it'll stop. So he's trying to grab the wing and the wing flies off. The little moment I love about that is the wing flies off and he looks back at it real quick, and in that moment, I'm like, so, now, I know some people have issues with Man of Steel and how there was a lot of destruction and maybe he didn't try to save as many people as he should.

57:32 I like that little moment because I think I don't think he's looking back at that wing gone oh well, crap, look what happened. I think he's looking back at it going where is that gonna fall? And is that gonna hit anybody? Nope, Okay, back to the plane. So it's just a little like it. It's not spoken. You don't even really see his face. You just see and I think that's probably the cgi double of Brandon Ralph too, like just a quick look back and then he's back to the plane. This is also the first time in the movie you see him in full costume. So this and so this is the big reveal. This. I think this sets up so much. Even where maybe later parts of the movie maybe falter a little bit, I think this scene sets up so much goodwill that you can kind of ride the coattails of this scene for a good portion of the movie, and you're like, I love this movie. This is great. You have like you I think you had mentioned you have some of the stuff where when he does finally save the plane, you know, we land it in the middle of the baseball field. Everybody's screaming and cheering and having a great time.

58:31 It's the best baseball the best baseball game some of these kids I've ever seen. And then you know, he's got that comment about you know, statistically speaking, flying is still the safest way to travel. It is. It's still very much a Christopher Reeve esque Superman it is, you know. And the the camera work that has done on this, the work they could do now with the you know, talking about the the z axis and the depth of the shots. You know, you had the X axis and the y axis, before you had the left and right, you had the up and down. But now you're getting these shots being able to see you know, he is zooming towards the camera or he is you know this this this movement of you know, away from or towards the audience into the background, like all of this stuff that you couldn't really do before, and they're using that CGI sparingly. They're using it just right to do it when they need to do it, but then it's practical when it needs to be practical. And I just I love that. I love the little look Lois gives when something flashes past the window and he's been gone for five years. There is no hint that he should have been coming back at all, and yet the plane's going down, something flashes past the window, and that little like sideways glance she gives that says more than you need to say without any amount of dialogue. There is so much said in that scene with no dialogue at all, and I think technically storytelling wise, character building, it just it is absolutely one of my favorite scenes of the whole movie.

1:00:00 When you look at the nostalgia that singers trying to build from the you know, the connective tissue from from Superman Returns to the Donner films. You know you're talking about this is the big reveal, right, this is like, you know, the first time Lois has seen him, well, she's seen him in five years, and you got to tie that to like the first time they ever met the first time we see the big reveal, you know, back in seventy eight, when he saves her from the helicopter crash. It's that's probably that's a top five. Moment in the history of cinema for me. I'm getting I'm getting goosebumps just thinking about it. But I am too, because I'm sitting here thinking, like of the cinematic moments, just that line of I've got you, You've got me.

1:00:46 Who's that you well, it's like, it's it's that script is so amazing because you have an iconic line like that, But then there's an iconic line like from just a Day Player. I always think of the woman he got her. I can't believe he just he just got her, even like the pimps, Hey jim Oh, it's it's it's amazing. And the fact that singer finds a way to take a moment like that and build on it and make it bigger and bigger, stakes and and still and you're watching, you're like, whoa, you know it it's an It's an incredible scene.

1:01:30 I'm glad. I'm glad you talked about that one, because I want to talk about a scene I don't know that if it's the pivotal moment, but I think it might be because this is Superman returns, and. The whole thing is why is he back? The whole thing. You know, she wins the the Pulitzer Prize for writing an article why the world doesn't need Superman. Right, we've moved on. And I want to talk about the scene that I think might be the pivot moment. And it's it's it's some really good dialogue. When he meets her on the roof of the Daily Planet and you know, she's she's kind of got some some feelings, you know, you know you.

1:02:16 Left, she's she's a little snarky. But he right, he know, he looks at her, He's like, you know, he wrote that the world doesn't need a savior, but every day I hear people crying for one. And in that moment, I feel like he validates his reason for being, you know, and kind of puts it to you know, challenges are like, yeah, you think I'm not needed, but guess what, you know I am. You know, I'm I'm I'm needed here, and uh, it's it's a it's a powerful bit of dialogue and it's even set up. There's a nice little setup whether you know, uh, James Marsin's Richard White. He's like, does he so if he can he can hear everything?

1:02:58 Does he hear everything like at the same time, or she's like yeah, yeah, I yeah, you know, and Clark's in the background kind of you know that you get that moment of like, that's. All you I'll call you know, Superman sixty four. How do you think Clark is? You know, you know, and she's rattling off his stats, you know, yeah, two twenty five sixty four, blah blah blah, you know, likes pink. Like likes pink. Yeah. Love love that moment how it kind of sets up their their talk on the on the rooftop. But just just a great moment between the two of them, and it's one of the better moments I think between the two of them in the film. Let's fly through some numbers here, John, I know we got we got some listeners that love hearing little facts like this, so we won't.

1:03:40 I won't stay long on them, you know, faster than a speeding bullet here, I'll do this. Superman Returns released on June twenty first, two thousand and six, with a one hundred and fifty four minute runtime that was actually trimmed down. Singer shows the film to some trusted friends who give him some notes and then he made he made his own cut before releasing it. It opens to no one's surprise. It opens at number one with fifty two point five million dollars. Its opening weekend goes on to gross three hundred and ninety one million from a budget of two hundred and four million, and I think at the time it takes over as the biggest five day release, beating the Matrix revolutions.

1:04:24 No surprise. There an IMDb score of six point one out of ten. I think it should be a little bit higher. It is a seventy two percent fresh on Rotten Tomatoes. And this one surprises me, John because critics and audiences they responded well to this when it first comes out. But it receives a B plus grade from audiences pulled by cinema score. Don't know what you're you're asking for. But yeah, that's because B plus is low for cinema score you typically have, especially for a movie like this. If you're going to see a Superman movie, yeah, you know what you're expecting with a Superman movie, so typically like, I feel like the lower scores you get for those are gonna be like an anus maybe B plus if you weren't happy.

1:05:09 But yeah, yeah, well at any rate, I know, I know we got to take a break. I also know we've got something nice. In in mind for our Patreon listeners, So come right back. We'll start wrapping things up. But if you are listening on Patreon right now, our beloved Patreon family, you're not going anywhere because we've got some bonus material for you. So if you're not on Patreon, now's a good time to hit pause on that Spotify playlist or Apple or Podbean or good Good Pods, whatever you're listening on, and maybe go head over to patreon dot com slash a film by podcast because you can sign up right now for a free seven day trial.

1:05:55 And what better time because we've got John Reid who's gonna supply us with a little extra material for this episode. So we'll see you there and if not, we'll see you in about ninety seconds. Welcome back. Uh, it is time to wrap things up. John. I'm gonna ask you, if someone watches Superman returns this blockbuster of a film. And made four hundred million dollars. How successful does that have to be? Right? Made million dollars? Sorry, no, I haven't. But if someone's looking at you, John, and they say, hey, look you this this Brian singer guy, I get it.

1:06:41 He's he's super he does Superman, he's as x Men. But is there anything a little more underrated? Uh? Some kind of like a hidden Jim any kind of project you would recommend, whether he's written it, whether he's directed it. Maybe he was in it, John, what would you recommend for a new Brian's your fan to check out? So I one of my one of my all time favorites. I mean the X Men movies obviously, like I I love his X Men movies. But the one of his that and I didn't really I don't think I watched this until after I had seen Superman Returns the X Men movies. Uh. The one of his that I absolutely love is Usual Suspects. Fantastic is such a fantastic movie, and I you know that and another one with Kevin Spacey, but that that whole twist at the end, Like I'm I'm a sucker for a movie that does a twist. Well, you know, like your your sixth sense or your usual suspects.

1:07:39 That is that is outstanding the so I'm gonna say that one. I'm also gonna say kind of the weird, quirky little one that I have not seen in years, but I remember when I did see it, I enjoyed it was. Uh he did kind of a bit of a remake of the Monsters with Mockingbird Lane. Oh yeah, yeah TV. Yeah, it was, it was. It was. It was weird, it was quirk but it was I like weird and querky sometimes. So it has been years since I've seen it, but I kind of have some memories of that as like, I remember that being pretty fun as a TV movie. That's a good one. Well, I'm gonna recommend a movie that he did in nineteen ninety eight. We actually covered it way back on our very first season. Listeners, go back, check that one out.

1:08:23 But just you know, give us a little little leeway. I mean, that's that's season one where we didn't know. We didn't know about audio quality, John, We didn't. We were learning, we were finding our way. But film called apt Pupil, which it's a psychological thriller that he directed with Brian that he's directed had brad Renfrow and sir Ian. McKellan in it. Yes, really cool movie. It's based off of Stephen King novella from I Think This, I Think that one's in different seasons. They I'll give you a fun fact here, just a quick plug for apped pupil. They originally intended to make that film in nineteen eighty four and James Mason was in the role that sir Ian McKellen took on, but production halts because he dies of a heart attack before filming.

1:09:17 Oh wow, So they say, okay, let's. Talk to Richard Burton, and while Burton is in talks to replace James Mason, he too dies from a cerebral hemorrhage. And at that point they're like, okay, we're just put on the shelf. We'll try again a couple of years. So John, I look, I know we are two of the biggest fans of Superman. Our bias dictates that we're going to recommend Superman returns am I correct and saying that, yeah. All right, yeah, it's it's I mean, it definitely has its flaws, and there's there's a couple of things here and there, but it's I would not skip over this one at all. And let's be fair, is there a Superman or Superman a jacent film that you wouldn't recommend. It's a tough call for for us, but I just wanted to see, and it's okay to say.

1:10:08 No, probably not. I'm and I want to preface this by saying I'm not. I know there's there's a lot of stuff online about, you know, bringing back the Snyder Verse and all that other stuff. I'm I am not one of them bring back the Snyder Verse people. But I will say, having watched and enjoyed, having watched and enjoyed the original Justice League, I also have a copy of Zack Snyder's Justice League, and awesome, that is the version I will watch from now on. In fact, I'm not even sure where my Justice League copy is, but I know exactly where my Zack Snyder's Justice League copy is. That's the one. So I maybe maybe the ones that I wouldn't recommend would be the ones that are maybe older versions where we've now gotten an update and we have a different version of it. Maybe the original Justice League, even even a weird, weird movie like Quest for Peace, is still worth watching.

1:11:05 It's still fun, even Supergirl, Supergirl still fun to watch. Oh yeah, oh yeah. I know it's an awful movie, but it's I love watching. I'm I've had one or two people at different points in time have given me the title of defender of the filth, and so I am. I am willing to take that title and defend even some really bad stuff. I'll even argue the Bollywood Superman movie that came out in nineteen eighty seven, it's worth a watch. Does it make any sense at all? No? Does it have some fun dance sequences. Absolutely? Yes, yeah. Look, you could join John Reid in Chicago for some deep dish Chicago style pizza.

1:11:47 Oh absolutely. And that's that's that's that's that's top dollar, right, That's that's that's living it up. And you can also go to your local grocery store and you can buy a microwave pizza. At the end of the day, it's you're gonna enjoy it, right. I feel like that's how it is. A Superman even a bad Superman movie is a good time. So this one, like all the super I think it's I think it's every Superman title. They're all streaming on HBO Max on the DC. Tab or channel or whatever whatever the streamer calls it. But it's there to check out. We hope you will continue to check out not only the A Film By Podcast, but the thirty something Movie Podcast if you have not done so yet. Next time on a Film Buy, we'll be talking about that other superhero sequel of two thousand and six starring James Marsden, talking about Brett Ratner's X Men, The Last Stand. If you've seen it, how would you summarize it in exactly five words? You can go to a film by podcast dot com give us your answer, or email us at a film by Podcast at gmail dot com. If we use your five words synopsis on the show, we will definitely show you out and we will give you We'll send you some of that A Film by swag. And please join us on all the social media channels, especially YouTube, where we are now doing our previously on limited series with with Garrett Gibson talking about some of our favorite television shows and yours. We love the comments we're seeing

1:13:21 on YouTube. We love the interaction, so keep that up. If you have not done so, check it out, hit like, hit subscribe. We are happy to have you there. John, I want to thank you again. What's a thirty something movie podcast? What do you guys got? What's coming at us? Can we can we get a little preview? Yeah? Yeah. So we So we're in nineteen ninety six right now, so we're in the we're in the middle of that. We started off the year with like Mission Impossible, Multiplicity the Phantom, So that was that was how we kicked off the year. And then lately we're kind of we're jumping into summertime now and we just got done with we had well, we had here's a weird lineup for you. We ended the month of March that was our four kids month, and then we rolled into April, which is are definitely not for kids month, So back to back weeks. We had Matilda at the end of March, and then we had Bound at the beginning of April.

1:14:17 So I want to talk about like a little bit of whiplash in terms of what kind of movies we're watching, a little bit of whiplash there. We had a lot of fun in the month of May. We were doing because there's oddly enough, there are four movies in nineteen ninety six that feature future Phantom Menace actors, and so May we called pre prequel parts and we did train Spotting with Ean McGregor, We did Mars Attacks with Natalie Portman, we did Jingle All the Way with Jake Lloyd, and we did a Time to Kill with Samuel L. Jackson, so that it was a lot of fun. We we missed out on Time to Kill when we did our limited ninety six, and I was like, it's fine, they're gonna hit it.

1:15:03 They're gonna I mean, I love, I love, I'm loving all. Of them from ninety six obviously, but I was a big fan of the Mars Attacks one. Definitely big fan of the Time to Kill one. So thank you for what you guys do. It is it's just awesome. We're I mean, okay, so I know you're I know you're. You guys are one of the ogs, like you're like you mentioned like, hey, but what the hell's the podcast? You guys been in the game for a while, like the godfathers of this thing? Are you on all the social media channels? Website? Can you tell us real quick? How do we like? Where are we finding you everywhere? Yeah? Pretty much? We are ebbs and flows on some of the socials. We're kind of we're trying to decide if how much of the socials we're gonna keep doing, or if we're going to kind of shift over to focusing a little bit more on like a newsletter where we can get a little bit more some like long form stuff. I've got a couple of people that may want to contribute to some of that, so we're kind of we're kind of back and forth on that a little bit. But if we are on the socials Blue Sky, Twitter, Facebook, all those Instagram, those different spots at three zero podcast, if you go to our website though, three zero theWord podcast dot com that has all the links to any of the social media spots that we're on. So we're varying degrees of activity on the socials. Right now, we'll always post up the new episodes and everything else on there, but we're kind of we're trying to kind of look at what the future looks like like are we going to shift over and spend a little bit more dedicated time on would we get some more traction with a newsletter or are we going to stick to, you know, sharing it out on the socials. So it's kind of head to the website. That's the best place to get

1:16:34 a hold of where our stuff is. Right. We will link the website on our show notes. People check that out so you can find it. Again. John, I want to thank you. I've had a I've been looking forward for a while, not only just having you on the Film By podcast, but if there was an opportunity to have a Superman discussion with you, and you know, I would have shared the opportunity with any of our buddies or any of our our co hosts, but this was a rare treat for me to have the great John Reid all to myself, Superman fan, a Superman fan. And and can I and can I spoil something real quick?

1:17:14 Please? Yeah? I think I think I can spoil this anybody who's listening to this in or near October. I think you're going to join us for an episode in October. Yes, I think we're gonna get We're gonna get Batman versus Joerel. Mm hmmm yeah, yeah, yeah. I I was thrilled when I was like, hey, you sent that out, and I was like, how about yeah, yeah, we'll leave it at Batman versus Jirell, but. We'll let the people figure it out. But yeah, yeah, yeah, I'll tell you what you figured it out, you you write it, I'll send you one of our T shirts. How about that. There you go. Boom uh. But to all of you out there listening to the show, following us on social media, subscribing to YouTube, supporting us on Patreon, especially as.

1:17:57 An episode like this it had a it's just packed full of Patreon extra stuff. We thank you and we'll see you next time. M hmmm.